Subject: Cost of a 240 HP peripheral port engine.
From: Paul
Date: 2/5/1999, 2:28 PM
To: z

Jeff Spitzer wrote:

At 11:47 PM 2/4/99 -0800, you wrote:
Chuck_Harbert@arkwright.com wrote:

Paul, I've been reading the correspondence on peripheral ports with
interest. I talked to Skip Gorman who raced this type of engine and he said
that this was a full race type application, if you're planning on making
250hp. It barely runs under 6,000 rpm, makes a tremendous amount of noise,
and gulps fuel like there's no tomorrow. It also takes very tuned intake
and exhaust systems to get this kind of HP. The torque also is not much
under 6K. I thought Everitt was using a PP engine and that he was looking
at about 200 hp using butterfly valves to make it idle. He spent a bunch of
time developing a compatible airplane engine.

All this doesn't sound to me like a good (reliable, econmical, reasonably
priced) airplane engine. If you want 250 hp out  of a 13B, why don't you
just turbo it? Then it's good for altitude speed, as well. Couldn't stand
to keep quiet.

Paul <rotaryeng@earthlink.net> on 02/01/99 09:50:56 AM


I think that is an exaggeration. The engine does indeed generate
quite a lot of HP below 6000 RPM. An aircraft engine is not like a
car engine. There is no real need to run it much below 4000 RPM.
The noise should be roughly the same as the exhaust port is
unchanged. The noise should be relative to the amount of HP it is
generating.

 On a PP rotary intake noise is very comparable to exhaust noise.
We had an OMC SAE paper that quoted unmuffled intake noise as high as 140
dB for some conditions.

Wow! 140 db is painful! Is that with or without the K&N air filter on
there?

 
The guys don't seem to be getting the HP with the
side ports. People with 180 HP and 200 HP aircraft engines in RV's
and Lancairs are going much faster. Everett's peripheral port
engine was the only rotary that could run with them.

The BSFC in fact is better with
the peripheral port as the VE is higher. The Le Mans peripheral port
engine proved that.

BSFC and VE are only very loosely connected.  The truth to the worse BSFC
for PP is loss of mixture through the overlap.  If the porting does not
include overlap then the power gains are not as significant.  Take your
pick.  If the tuning and speed are *just right* then the BSFC and power can
both be good.  Gotta dyno? ;)

Jeff Spitzer

The Le Mans engine had PP's and overlap and it had excellent BSFC
by rotary engine standards throughout a wide range .
See SAE 920309 "Mazda 4-Rotor Rotary Engine for the Le Mans
24-Hour Endurance Race". The race was partially a fuel 
efficiency thing in that you only had so much fuel to run the
race on as I recall. Something like that.


If you want better BSFC you are just going to have to build a turbo
compound rotary. :-) BTW I just updated the web site with more on
turbo compounding among other things.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org