David Carter wrote:
Alan Tolle wrote:>
<snip>
There is adequate room for everything inside the cowl EXCEPT for one
important point, something which has been mentioned on these pages before
and which should be getting the attention now being given to trying to get a
large enough radiator in a belly scoop or a tail cone. It has made no
sense to me to saddle a beautifully compact engine like the 13B
with a gear box (you call it a PSRU) longer than the engine itself.
The planetary gear set only takes up 2 inches and 6 inches is
plenty long enough for the prop shaft. Perhaps the engineers in this
forum can explain the necessity for all the extra length.
If there is no engineering explaination, why is the
extra length there? I would really like to know.
When the gear box is short enough (all of the Powersport
boxes were) there is adequate room between the engine and
the firewall for all the cooling radiators one will ever need.
The radiators do work there <snip>
This is the easiest way to solve the aircraft rotary engine
conversion cooling problem <snip>
I learned that to get the right answer one had to first ask the right question.
Perhaps this forum has been addressing the wrong question.
The real need here may be for a shorter gear box, not a radiator
in a belly scoop.
<snip> There is no intention here to start any arguments <snip>
(signed) Alan Tolle
Paul responded and posted:
Thanks Allen. I agree with you on the PSRU length and hopefully the New
Power Sport and Tracy Crook are addressing this issue as we speak.
<snip>
The main reason for a near vertical rad and a long in and out ducts is
an attempt to reduce cooling drag. <snip> Unfortunately you are
asking the air to make two sharp 90 degree bends and the exit duct is
not of ideal shape or location.
David Carter chimes in about the "psru length" vs "problem of radiator
location":
1. There's not a problem with space in Dave Atkin's RV-6 cowl for
radiator and stock Mazda oil cooler. And apparently not a problem in
Tracy Crook's RV-4.
- Therefore I disagree that there is a "real problem" looking for a
"real solution"
+ We just need to pay attention to details like Tracy did with shape
of lips of his cowl where air dumped into the "plenum; and like David
did on his horizontally mounded radiator, sealing all around it so ALL
air that came in the left air hole up front either went into engine
intake or through radiator. He's not refining anymore - it works.
2. Neither Tracy nor David has the radiator(s) "behind the engine".
Both are more forward.
- Therefore, psru length is a non-issue.
- I believe the issue of "psru length" goes back a long way and is a
serious personal and/or marketing problem that the Powersport folks have
- pride in their expensive, out of reach solutions that are totally out
of the "market" of us "low budget" home builders that just want to fly
and do so by buying "off-the-shelf-stuff" that is currently flying
successfully in other similar airplanes, and that costs less than "FAA
certified" stuff, more on the order of "auto certified" stuff.
+ Chris Ross has a shorter version of his 2.17 to 1 psru: 3" shorter
than original 14.25 length (i.e., 11.25 inches long)
+ Since the "extra/unexplained/engineeringly unjustified length"
happens to be about what it takes to keep an RV from being tail heavy,
I'm not looking for anyone to take the time and give an engineering
explanation of "why is it that long if the gears are only this long?"
What I would rather know is: How much more do I have to pay for the
exotically short psru vs the Ross psru? More of a pocket-book question
than an engineering question. But, I'm not a college trained engineer,
just a guy with a small pocketbook who flies a little and wants to fly
a LOT more.
In 1997 at Oshkosh, David Atkins had his stock Mazda oil cooler hanging
straight down in the breeze, about like a WWI Jenny with a big OX-5
radiator sticking up in the breeze- that was a temporary solution to a
problem he found in Kansas in the summer.
Since then, he's put louvers on right side of cowling and mounted stock
Mazda oil cooler
longwise there with right air scoop feeding just the oil cooler. Left
side
air scoop feeds both engine air induction and cooling radiator, with
radiator lying horizontal but sealed so all air from left scoop that
doesn't go into engine goes through the radiator. No cooling problem. >
David Carter, building RV-6, planning on 13B engine
There are two situations here David. Lot's of things will work.
If you just want to get in the air almost any arrangement will
do including hanging the radiator out in the airstream and it
will work at some continuous power level and at some airspeed.
This is why cross country racing in an established race event
is so important in the experimental aircraft movement.
You prove to the world that your system cools at such and
such an airspeed. Only Power Sport/Allan Tolle has done
that so far with the rotary engine.
At this point in time we are focused on reducing cooling drag
(even beyond what Allan Tolle and Power Sport have achieved)
so the airplane becomes more useful for cross country use.
Better MPG and higher cruising speeds. IMHO I think it can be done.
RV6's are going 230 MPH with 180 HP and RV4's are going 240 MPH
with 200 HP. The big difference is cooling drag.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org