Subject: Inconel & Stainless - A Metallurgist's Explanation
From: Paul
Date: 2/25/1999, 1:29 PM
To: z

David Carter wrote:

July 1998 Experimenter, pp 29-30, quoted the March 1997 "Cessna Pilots
Association Magazine article by Alan Caddey, Metallurical Engineer,
Renton Coil Spring Company.  (This is one to read and save.)

        "Low carbon austenitic stainless steels are often used for small
aircraft exhaust systems.  One caveat used in this application is a
recommended upper temperature limit of 1600 degrees F.  Above this
temperature, several metallurgical mechanisms deteriorate the service
life of the components at a much higher rate than normal, hence the need
to limit the time of exposure to temperatures above 1600 degrees F.  A
managed exposure to engine exhaust temperatures, by incorporation of
appropriate temperature gauges, can be successfully used to deter
exhaust sytem corrosion and improve component life expectancy.
        "Aircraft engines incorporating the use of turbochargers are more
susceptible to high temperature exhaust system exposure than are
normally aspirated aircraft.  Turbos typically have a maximum
recommended turbine inlet temperature (TIT) of around 1650 degrees F but
experience has shown that, depending on power settings and fuel flow,
the actual temperature can rise to as high as 1730 degrees F.  By
properly managing the power settings and subsequent exhaust
temperatures, exposure to temperatures above 1600 degrees F can be
minimized.
        "Metallurgically, between 1600 degrees F and about 1770 degrees F,
chromium carbide precipitation is very active at the stainless steel
grain boundaries." [Carter adds:  Chome is the alloy that makes
stainless steel "stainless"/hi temp resistant - loss of chome is what
he's going to talk about now.]  "This leads to depletion of chromium at
the boundaries and a markedly increased susceptibility to preferential
grain boundary (intergranular) attack.  This phenomenon is commonly
knows as "sensitization" and leaves the metal susceptible to attack by
any corroding (oxidizing) medium such as hot exhaust gases.   The
corrosion is selectively oxidized on the surface at elevated
temperatures, leading to further chromium depletion of the metal.  As
the overall chromium content falls, so does the corrosion resistance of
the metal.
        "Coupled with these high-temperature reactions is the stainless steel
reaction with hydrocarbon (carbon-containing) exhaust gases at elevated
temperatures.  Carbon is absorbed and subsequently diffuses into the
alloy interior.  Carbides of the reactive alloying elements, including
chromium, are then precipitated in the steel matrix and grain boundaries
(known as "carburization"), adding to the overall depletion of chromium,
and thereby completing a circle of increasing sensitization and high
temperature corrosion.  As carburization continues, ductility and impact
properties of the metal substrate fall, depending on the degree and
distribution of the absorbed carbon.
        "All of these processes continue over time at temperatures above 1600
degrees F, leading to spalling of heavily carburized surfaces (i.e.,
metal loss) and finally to failure of the stainless steel component.  By
limiting or eliminating exposure to temperatures above 1600 degrees F,
the advantages of using austenitic stainless steels can be fully
utilized."

End of quote.  I assume the author's use of the generic term "austenitic
stainless steels" refers to what I have always heard as "306" "316"
"403" stainless (or something close to that).

David Carter


The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org