I have received several private email messages taking
me to task for recommending five inch square air outlet
holes under the stab of certain composite airplanes.
Hey guys I did not just fall off the composite turnip
truck :-) I designed and built my first epoxy glass foam
composite structure in 1960 for a military project.
Burt Rutan was still in high school :-).
It was an antenna mast. When we were not using it
as an antenna mast we used it as a crane boom to hoist
antennas up to the roof of the test building.
The picture is of the Chaparral 2F composite chassis.
It is from "Chaparral" by Richard Falconer.
The loads this structure see are far higher than
the loads a tail boom sees on an aircraft. When this
car is going around the banking at Daytona or Monza Italy
at 200 MPH and hits a bump the loads can exceed six G's.
The airplane only see's that when doing aerobatics if then.
The next message will show this picture.
Notice the stainless steel ring bonded and riveted to
the huge hole. Talk about differing materials.
Yes the Chaparral 2F had a composite chassis long before
it became popular for airplanes. We made several... differing
in the number of layers of 181 aircraft glass cloth.
It was pressure cured in an autoclave. Unfortunately
glass epoxy has a stiffness to weight ratio akin to
rubber band so we did away with it and went back to a
a 0.035 thick aluminum monocoque chassis. The weight for
a given stiffness dropped by half. This is one of
the main reasons glass composite airplanes are heavier
than aluminum airplanes.
Since Dr. Roberts, recently of the FAA and author
of the study on in flight
breakups caused by flutter feels that stiffness is
far more important than mere strength, you can see why
I recommended using carbon fiber to reinforce those holes
and looking at the experience of the stainless
re-inforcements on the Chaparral, why I felt the differing
materials whould be no problem.
Once something is strong enough you can add stiffness and
it will just get stronger!
BTW If you want to read one of my articles on the subject
try looking this up in the library.
Monocoque (chassis design) by Paul Lamar
Sports Car Graphic July 1966
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org