Subject: Are air cooled aircraft engines modern?]
From: Paul
Date: 2/27/1999, 11:08 PM
To: z

Bill Freeman wrote:

    SNIP

. On the other hand with aircooling
you need a lot of piston clearance.


  I think Porsche knows a thing or three about
aircooled engine design - note that the latest rage in aircraft
cylinder refurbishment is to go to what Porsche has been using for
new production for 25 years!.

My Lyc factory shop manual says the piston skirt to cyl clearance
new should be from 0.011" to 0.016" inch for my O-235 in my
Long EZ.  My Porsche 911 factory shop manual says
use 0.0018" to 0.0025" for my 911SC.  The O-235 has
a larger bore, so an adjustment of about 25% is in order,but
the problem is piston design, cylinder design and cooling
system design.  Small clearance can be done.

That said, I suspect that it is  a lot cheaper to do without
a cooling fan and use large piston skirt clearances.  I imagine
that if Lyc and Cont. went to aluminum cylinders with
NIKASYL plating on the bore (like all 911s since '74) the
differential expansion problem (alum piston/steel cyl)
would decrease and the piston clearance would also
greatly decrease.

VW ran similar clearances in thier aircooled motors, with
cast iron cyls and aluminum pistons.

Also, German cars are the only auto motors that can claim
the ability to run at high fractions of rated power for
extended periods much lie A.C. engines due to their
speed limitless autobahns.

I understand that this is less true today due to lower
sustained speeds possible with traffic congestion.

Bill

Bill, Porsche probably uses low expansion aluminum
material for pistons. I think it is called Eutectic or
something like that. I also think it has to be cast
rather than forged. This is a relatively recent 
development and there is probably nothing much
to be gained in aircraft applications. Cold piston
slap is probably the big advantage for cars.
It is probably not worth the cost to Lyc and Cont
to recertify the engines with this piston alloy.
I could be totally wrong about all this. This is
all from memory alone.

You are right about the speeds in Europe. They are way
down. Also speed governers are now typical on fast cars
which further limits the sustained HP. Not to mention you
get where you are going in Europe in short order at 
150 MPH. I have been going over there since about 1980.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org