Subject: Are air cooled aircraft engines modern?
From: Paul
Date: 2/27/1999, 2:54 PM
To: z

Archie Frangoudis wrote:


 If anyone has attended any of my seminars at OSH, you
know I have no love for conventional aircraft engines,(even though
my shop performs routine surgery on them).
Myth: Aircraft engines burn oil as part of their design.
B.S+ACE- The technology they employ is akin to a model A Ford.
In fact their design can be traced further back than that, with only
minor improvements since then. 

[Come on Archie they are not that bad. Materials and detail design
are vastly improved. BTW the model A engine made a pretty good AC
engine because it had a lot of displacement for it's modest power
level and could be run at low RPM to directly drive the prop.] 

One of my customers has an O-200
built in my shop that has no appreciable oil consumption in 173hrs.
I am not tooting my own horn, the technology is there for all.
Would you buy a new car if the salesperson told you it will consume
a quart every 5-10 hrs?
What would your reaction be if you opened the hood and saw a
Lycoming, Franklin, or Continental in there.
Would you buy the pitch that because it is an aircraft engine is
it is more dependable and trustworthy?

[I tell you one thing Archie. It is a lot heavier duty than your
car engine. It * IS * more dependable and trustworthy at the power
levels AC engines are required to run at.] 

And, you can gap your plugs at .025 instead of .050 or more.

[Nothing stopping you from putting electronic ignition on them.
Aircraft Spruce is even selling automotive spark plug adapters for
AC engines.]

If these engines are so great, why after 60 or so years are new AD's
coming out? After all this time, they still don't have it right+ACE-
And, because of their shortcomings, YOU still pay for these AD's.

[AD's are now a manufacturing issue and not a design issue. Many
AD's are just a product liability duck.]

The verdict is still out on the ideal aircraft engine, but at least
automotive is not stagnating.
Better stop now, before going off the deep end, or I may write
several pages on this.
Archie

I feel your frustration Archie and that's why I started this
news letter. I think the rotary would make a better aircraft engine.

A lot of the differences are due to the prop RPM problem
and air-cooling. You can see the trouble we are having with
liquid-cooling. A fundamental advantage of AC engines is 
the difference in temp with aircooling is far more favorable 
for heat transfer reasons. On the other hand with aircooling 
you need a lot of piston clearance.
 
However I don't want to encourage this debate because it is almost
a religous type of thing. People believe and that's it.

PL

The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org