Alan Tolle wrote:
I will visit this subject one more time. Since the technically oriented
appreciate details (numbers) I will include them.
The kit or plans built experimental aircraft is the only current market for
the installation of a rotary engine conversion. Nearly every such aircraft
was designed around the four cylinder Lycoming engine, usually the 0320
series, so the normal weight and balance on these aircraft depends on using
that engine. In occasionally heavier (the 0360) and lighter (the 0290 or
0235) engine installations CG compensation consisted of proper relocation of
the battery. A few aircraft used lead ballast.
If the builder is going to install a rotary conversion rather than the
Lycoming 0320 there are many things to be considered, including engine mount
design, cooling, apex seal lubrication, intake and exhaust systems, fuel
injection, and the list goes on and on. All topics are relevant and
hundreds of thousands of words have been devoted to them on these pages.
It is simply my intention to direct the (potential) builder's attention to
another subject which can not be ignored, the subject of center of gravity.
First, I consulted my Lycoming handbook for the 0320 series and computed the
installed running weight of that engine, which is 368 pounds, +/- 10 pounds.
I included in this weight the oil, oil cooler and hoses, and the engine
mount for reasons of the comparison below. Then I went out to the hangar
and measured the distance from the crankshaft propeller flange to the
lifting eye to determine the engine center of gravity. That distance is 14
inches. When the weight of the engine mount is included the distance
becomes 14.5 inches.
Next, I dug out the very first issue of the Contact monograph published by
Mick Myal. The major article in that issue was written by Chris Ross. On
page 13 of that article there is a table which lists the running weight of
the rotary engine installation at 340 pounds. This list includes engine
mount, oil, and oil cooler, which is why these items were included in the
Lycming computation. The calculated center of gravity of the engine
installation from that table is 21.1 inches from the propeller (crankshaft)
flange. I assume the validity of these numbers based on their source and I
note that Powersport numbers, for the engine and accessories at least, were
very similar.
>From the above numbers two conclusions may be made. The Lycoming engine is
heavier than the rotary engine by a factor of about 30 pounds and the
center of gravity of the Lycoming is forward in the cowling by a factor of
6.6 inches. (Propellers and spinners were not included in the
calculations since both engines would use the same item in the same place.)
Very interesting!
Last, I got out the center of gravity computation pages from my RV-6A
builders manual. The example given in that manual is taken from the factory
prototype which is identical to the kit aircraft. The calculations are
done by Dick VanGrunsven in his own hand. Using standard calculations I
"removed" from the factory protorype the Lycoming engine and "installed"
the rotary conversion based on weights and locations described above. The
results?
The empty weight center of gravity of the prototype RV-6A moved aft 3.5
inches with the rotary engine installation Further calculation showed
that with full fuel, two 170 pound occupants, and 32 pounds of baggage the
CG would be right at the aft limit. Fuel burn would take the CG aft so that
at the end of a 3.5 hour cross country flight with that same load the CG
would be 1.1 inches beyond the aft limit. If a pilot took a friend for a
ride with half of a fuel load and no baggage, the aircraft CG would already
be beyond the aft limit when the aircraft left the ground.
Certainly an aircraft loaded beyond the aft CG limit will fly. Most of us
have made such a flight at one time or another, some knowingly, some not.
Some will even say that an aft CG is no big deal. However, I can name a
dozen pilots who would argue with you, if they were alive today to argue.
I would still use the shortest gear box possible and mount the engine as far
forward as possible in the cowling. If you are locked into something else,
be aware of the potential danger, and be careful. A word to the wise is
sufficient.
The empty weight of Van's RV6-A prototype calculated out at 967 pounds with
the rotary engine installation. I am still at a loss to know why Anderson's
weighs 1170 pounds. There is something here which is not readily apparent.
No criticism is intended --- I just don't understand it. Mainly because my
first two RV-3's with 0320 angines weighed almost exactly the same as the
last -3 with the Powersport 200 engine.
One other conclusion can be taken from this paper. The weight saving of the
13B conversion is negligable compared with the Lycoming 0320 that it might
replace. It might be in the order of 10%. I sort of remenber seeing and
hearing some claims of major weight savings. I doubt it.
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org