Anderson Ed wrote:
Agree that holding rad vol the same, that the thinner rad would
be more efficient and dissapate more BTUs not only because of temp
differential across it, but with the same vol the thinner rad would have
more frontal surface area compared to the thicker one and therefore
capture more airflow. Biggest drawback I can see for thinner in aicraft
installation (particularly under the cowl) is space and mounting
considerations. Airflow drag may also be signficant between the two. As
you know, frontal area is the one thing that you most often try to
minimize in aircraft for the HP^3 reasons stated in several post. So
larger thinner radiators would just about have to be on the bottom, top
or rear of the engine in most tractor under the cowl installations.
Smaller and thicker is the constrain to mounting them forward. Also,
while most installations will work with OAT cold enough, I think the
acid test will be ground cooling on 100F+ days.
Jim Mosur's installation, Tracy's and Mine are very similar with Tracy
and I using almost identical radiators. Major difference between Tracy
radiator setup and mine is that he uses parallel flow and I use Serial
flow to the two radiators. I appear to be the only one that ducts the
hot radiator air to the side of the cowl to exit out the louvers. I did
this because I felt that dumping the hot air exiting the radiator back
on the engine was causing part of my overheat problem on hot days. The
angle of the radiators to airflow of mine and Tracy's look very similar,
Jim's looks to have somewhat more angle. I know Jim has been flying
mostly in cooler winter weather as have I. So when its <30F OAT probably
all of our installations will work just fine. The proof of the pudding
will be on those 100F days.
Ed Anderson
There is one other differences. Thicker under the cowl
at a low angle implies external diffusion while thinner and bigger at a
greater angle implies more internal diffusion. Both seem to work
at about the same volume. We shall see this summer.
Paul
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org