David Carter wrote:
Bktrub@aol.com wrote Mar 10, 1999 12:33 am:
What type of engine damage are we talking about here? Engine damage due
to
over leaning usually burns exhast valves in a recip, what effect does
an
overly lean mixture have on a rotary?
B. Trubee
Good question.
Paul Lamar
I can't address damage from "lean" in context of an improperly plumbed
nitrous system. But for normally aspirated and turbocharged, running lean
can have two general results, depending on whether you are at or near wide
open throttle at or near sea level.
First, just like piston engines, given that ignition timing is correct, and
given that you are running at 75 per cent power or less (75% is nebulous;
really, "running well below detonation limits" is more accurate), running
lean cannot cause detonation. All you can do is reduce fuel burn, reduce
exhaust gas temperature, reduce power, and, depending on balance of fuel
air ratio in each rotor, maybe get some roughness, though not as likely as
in a piston engine. The ultimate effect is the engine will quit from a
mixture so lean it can't sustain combustion. Nothing too scary there, nor
too mysterious.
Second, if running at high power, you may be able to lean enough to get
detonation. The damage seen and reported in this e-mail forum is severe
spark plug damage: broken porcelin insulators and burned electrodes. In
two cases, the hard parts do not appear to have caused internal damage to
rotor seals, but that may not always be the case. If seals were damaged, a
complete teardown would be required.
What is "high power"? The question is implied in both scenarios above.
Here's a clue: Piston engine manufacturers and FAA have a "party line"
which suggests not leaning below 5000 feet (where wide open throttle is
only giving you 86% of sea level manifold pressure, not counting loss of an
inch or two across the air filter both at SL and at 5000'). I suspect they
are confident that the combination of 1) ignition advance they specify and
2) the 86% of SL ambient pressure to intake system cannot produce
detonation at any leaning you do, up to shutting the engine down.
Remember, when leaning drastically, you are further reducing power below
the detonation limits of your particular engine setup (ignition timing, and
for turbos, inlet air temperature and pressure).
David Carter
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org