Subject: Rotary engine weight, cooling, HP, etc., etc.
From: Paul
Date: 3/10/1999, 6:55 PM
To: z

Tracy Crook wrote:

Alan Tolle wrote:

I agree that the placement of the water radiator(s) in the aircraft of
Tracy, Ed, and Jim  as far forward as possible is a step in the right
direction weight and balance wise.  But I suspect that these
installations
are cooling limited.  By that I mean that when these engines are
producing
the 160 hp expected of them they will also  be producing more heat than
the
cooling systems can exchange.

I realize that for Tracy high performance was never an essential
ingredient
in his formula.   He clearly stated his objectives (modest performance at
a
modest price) in his project and I think he met them admirably.  (His
monograph has helped immensely in the guiding of others who desire to do
their own rotary engine conversions.)  He may have gone to top speed for
a
short time just to see what top speed was.  But I don't think that on a
standard day at sea level he could hold that power for 30 minutes without
runaway water and oil temperatures.   From the conversations Tracy and I
have had over the years I don't think that kind of performance is really
his
concern.  Other considerations, like fuel consumption, are more
important.
Hence all the work on EFI.   Correct me if I am wrong here, Tracy.   It
doesn't sound like either Ed or Jim has had the opportunity to explore
the
high performance end of flight testing as yet.


What you said about my performance goals is true, at least initially.   I
was not sure if ANY auto engine was capable of running at high power
continuously so I was willing to accept 40% power cruise if necessary.  The
RV series aircraft  made this a workable alternative because they perform
quite well at this power level.
As I and others (like yourself) gained experience with the engine, I now
feel confident that the Mazda rotary can run at full power (150 - 200 HP)
and not suffer for it.  I have slowly opened the envelope to the point where
I can operate at full power continuously  with OATs as high as 85 - 90
degrees.  Above that I have to back off a bit but there are no real
operational problems even in temperatures of  100 - 102.   We had all time
record high temperatures in that range for several weeks this past summer
(in Florida).   Incidentally,  cooling was better on a 100 degree day in
arid Arizona   than on a 93 degree day in humid Florida.

The only cooling problem I have on a standard day (59 deg. F, 29.92
barometer, 50% humidity) is keeping the engine warm enough (at 50% power)
cruise.  Optimum fuel economy occurs at about 180 deg. water temp & 190 deg
oil.  On a standard day they are 155 & 160 respectively, way too cool.  Even
at full throttle the temps are well below maximum on this kind of day.  When
the temperature is below 50 I have to stuff a rag in one of my cooling
inlets.  A cowl flap would eliminate this foolishness of course and I plan
to install one.  This is a far cry from where I was on the first flight when
I declared an emergency shortly after takeoff  due to high oil & water
temps.

It was a long process getting the cooling to work this well, most of the
work was in the area of proper duct & inlet shaping.  I am still using the
same heat exchangers as on the first flight.     Even though the plane &
engine is capable of running at high power now, I still spend a lot of time
at 40% power but this is just personal preference.  Even though a given
flight may take a bit longer, the more relaxed sound of engine & airframe
allows me to sit back, enjoy my favorite music and arrive feeling like I
could do another 4 hours in the cockpit.  And yes, part of it is my penchant
for efficiency.   When most pilots are thinking about MPH, I am thinking
MPG.  My 13B will drink 10 gph and go close to 200 MPH (at altitude)  but It
just feels better to burn 6 gph & go 170 (TAS at 12,500 ft).   That's the
setting I used on return from Copperstate last year.

Even though the engine is cooling well now, I'm always looking for ways to
improve it (for reduced cooling drag if nothing else) so I wanted to ask you
about the single "shark gill"  that was on top of the Powersport RV-4 engine
cowl.  Did that work well?   Judging from the blast of hot air that comes
through any small opening in my firewall, there must be considerable
pressure in the engine room behind my radiators.   The top of the cowl is
usually a low pressure area so this might be a quick & easy way to improve
airflow through my radiators.   Due to my aversion to fiberglass I've been
reluctant to try it.

Thanks for your input here Alan.  You are the only source of operational
information we have on Powersport's accomplishments.   I'm glad you were the
one out there flying the snot out of the rotary first.  Made it a lot easier
for the rest of us.

Tracy Crook
  rws@altavista.net

The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org