Subject: Oil & water temps too cool
From: Paul
Date: 3/15/1999, 11:53 PM
To: zz

Chuck_Harbert@arkwright.com wrote:

Paul, I've been spending a lot of time researching cooling systems and been
meaning to write to everyone about it for weeks. I believe I have
undersized my oil & water cooling system based upon Brice's advice when I
talked to him a few weeks ago. He has a similar situation using a turbo 20B
in a pusher.

He is using a 22 x 24 x 3 (528a/1584v) h2o rad, whereas I was using a 9 x
23 x 3 (207a/621v) (double pass)(propylene glycol), or about 40% of his
sizing. I'm adding a 15 x 17 x 2 (255a/510v) which will make my totals 462
sq in area and 1,131 ci volume which I hope will be adequate thru efficient
ducting. These numbers make some sense when you compare them to the 2 rotor
rad info you posted earlier.

For oil, Brice is using two 8 x 12 x 3 (192a/576v) and I'm using a 6 x 8 x
3.5 (48a/168v), plus an 11x 11 x 2 (121a/242v) for a total of 169 sq in
area and 410 ci volume. Since I've been told that about 1/3 of the cooling
load on a rotary is from the oil, these numbers hopefully, make some sense.

Pushers have a problem with airflow on the ground which is partly why we
need larger rads. I originally sized my radiators for 350 hp (recip
engine), but because of the much larger heat load of the rotary, this is
much too small.

I've been talking with Griffin radiator, as well as Evans NPG (non-aqueous
propylene glycol) (Dave Wright) about what would work best. What I've found
out could fill a book. NPG systems are a whole different set of
circumstances. You took their ad with you and you might remember that they
said "down sized radiator (less frontal area)", but I only just found out
how that is accomplished.  If pure water is 1.0, then 50/50 h20/ethylene
glycol is .8 for heat transfer, and NPG is .7. However, water will only
absorb about 9,300 btus/lb, whereas NPG will do 15,500 btu/lb. Thus, to
reduce rad size you must increase the flow rate for an NPG system. You do
that by eliminating or reducing the size of the thermostat and increasing
the pump speed. Modern cooling system design makes the choke point the
thermostat which ensures higher pressures in the cylinder head area which
is critical to avoid hot spots. They say that a 260 degF NPG temp has the
same cooling characteristics as a 220 degF water/glycol for hot
spots/detonation.

NPG boils at 370 degF, so they recommend you don't run anything larger than
a 7 psi cap. Evans is in suit with Corvette over the use of their system
which is why Corvette no longer uses NPG in the LT-1, but does use reverse
flow. There are a lot of racers using NPG successfully which was
corroborated by Griffin.

The other half of this was my discussion with Griffin. I think to sum up
the conversation, you'd result with the same thing your group has
determined. Thinner rads are better for heat transfer, but the limiting
factor is frontal area available, so you end up with multiple row units.
Other things that are critical is the flow rates thru the rad which can be
optimized. Lately, they are building triple pass rads for racers. A custom
aluminum radiator (15 x 17 x 2) from Griiffin is $6-700 which is pretty
steep. They are using turbolators in their oil cooler, but again very
expensive stuff. He says they have a very talented group of thermodynamic
engrs which can help you with you custom application. It might be worth a
phone call to talk to them before you go much further on you rad test rig.

The other update that I think might be of interest is the weight of the
turbo 20B. My plane ended up weighing over 150 lbs heavier than normal and
most of it is in the engine. Because I've had to add additional rads &
coolant, sheilding, etc., I'm estimating my engine weight at close to
480lbs. (versus 360 lbs for an IO 360). Brice told me his plane came in
heavier as well, but I didn't think I would be in that situation until I
weighed it this last weekend. I spent a lot of time and money trying to
keep the weight down, but didn't succeed very well. It's okay because I
want the high altitude power capability, but I wanted to let the group know
my results.

I'm hoping to fly this thing end of April (FAA willing). More later.


 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org