Subject: Various cooling arrangemenst for low wing airplanes.
From: Paul
Date: 3/15/1999, 10:49 AM
To: z

Anderson Ed wrote:

Nice summary graph!

To be accurate, I would like to note that my rads are not perpendicular
to the airflow as depicted.  They are actually angled approx 30 degrees,
similar in concept to Jim's just not as much.  However, my main reason
for any angle is for fitting under the cowl
otherwise I would have positioned them perpendicular to the airflow.
I guess I could start another round by questioning whether a
perpendicular rad with an exit duct produces less drag that an angled
rad (without exit ducts) dumping its exit air back on and around the
engine before exiting, but I won't{:>}.

Ed Anderson


Well I think I said that Ed. Except for the exit ducts.
To be complete I also believe your louvers are adding
drag somewhat off-setting the reduction in drag due to 
the exit ducts themselves.

B. Is sort of Ed Anderson's RV6 arrangement with
perpendicular rads. Ed's is really a compromise
between this and Ed Mosur's arrangement.


The thing is if you angle them a lot like Jim's you can use thinner rads
and it takes less pressure to force air through them and the internal 
diffuser works better. IMHO your setup is not bad I just think Jim's 
is better. I also think the improvement would not be worth the effort
at this stage of developement on your airplane. If I was starting
from scratch on an RV6 or RV8 I would use Jim's configuration fig. A 
or the zig-zag/NACA duct in figure D.

BTW These diagrams are not meant to be exact drawings of all low wing
airplanes. They are merely modified step and repeat skematics.

>From a PRIVATE response or two I may have to add skematics
kicking and screaming  :-)

Since these are educated guess's I don't think I could honestly assign
drag numbers to such subtle variations. These are gross guess's.

Hopefully we will somehow be able to measure some radiators soon
with a ground test rig. The leading candidate at the moment is
a Toyota rad sawed in half. Multiple Geo Metro/Suzuki Swift rads 
would also work as is. 

Since I don't want to load down my old van engine with 150 HP for 
minutes at a time I am trying to come up with
some money to rent a new pickup truck or van we can hang things out
the sliding side door. Feasible if the test are done on a 
dry lake bed. 

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org