Subject: Warp and IVO props.
From: Paul
Date: 3/17/1999, 10:34 AM
To: zz

Gary Palmer wrote:


  Jeff,
  Generally I have found Warp Drive to be pretty up front
about limitations of their product, certainly much more so than some other
prop vendors. Having lost my aircraft to a defective NSI variable pitch prop
incorporating Warp drive blades, I am particularly sensitive to that
problem; fortunately I am alive to talk about it.

      The good news is that we have Internet enabled groups such
as this that help us share invaluable information. What is really needed is
for an organization such as EAA to take the lead in compiling the good and
bad field experience with various experimental aviation products.

Unfortunately, given the legal climate, that is not going to happen. A
perfect example is that after I reported my NSI failure to EAA, I received a
copy of a compilation of various prop failures that had been reported to EAA
from Ben Owen . Approximately 70% of these were IVO props. Having said that,
there certainly are many applications where an IVO works just fine; the
problem is we don't know where the line is drawn. One was a Warp drive on a
VW conversion (which says more about the fragility of the VW cranks, than
the prop). The rest were a mixture of the classic cut down Aluminum props,
and yes some wood prop failures. It really is too bad that this information
isn't more generally available. End of rant!

        Regards........Gary


Some good ideas there Gary. Perhaps a little destructive testing
is in order :-). One idea is to build a rig that jerks the prop
back and fourth in the plane of rotation. That will simulate
the torque reversals you get from a large four cylinder
piston engine. A shaker table could also be used to 
catagorize the resonent modes. 

The EAA is pretty weak on science and engineering.
Too much spit and polish and not enough engineering. 

They should set up a lab somewhere to test
some of this stuff. Engines too. Sort of like an unoffical 
certification where they merely publish the results. 

I know there are legal problems but just bite the bullet, 
swallow a bitter pill and budget for lawyers. Heck I would 
volunteer to do the work if they provided a legal shield 
and the lab. 

This whole idea could go a long way to improve the safety 
record of homebuilt aircraft.

While I am on this soap box Oshkosh needs a 100 mile race 
too...like Sun N Fun.
 
Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org