It is good to receive comments and questions on these pages from the RV
builders. Goodness knows I have visited with hundreds of you over the
airplane cowl at the flyi-ins since 1993 when I joined Everett Hatch in this
endeavor. Having built the RV-3, -4, and -6, done two rotary engine
installations, and flown behind the rotary engine for 400 hours I can speak
first hand to your efforts. I realize that what I offer are my own
opinions, but you realize that those opinions are based on real world
experience. A lot of the opinions I read here are about "what I am going
to do," or "theoretically what I think you should do." It is best to
ignore the former and give some thought to the latter.. I certainly admit
to knowing very little about the special circumstances which relate to a
Lancair or a Long Eze, Others with first hand experience can address those
types.
If I were building an RV-3 or -4 today and planning a rotary installation,
and a number of you are, it would include the following.
Plan for, and be satisfied with 150 - 160 hp because that is what is readily
obtainable from the standard side port engine and is the hp for which the
aircraft were designed. Leave the development of peripheral porting and
turbochargiong to people who have expertise in those areas and who want to
go race. (BTW I wouldn't race a standard constructed RV-3 or -4 for all
the tea in China.) Most builders who read here simply want to fly, not set
records. I can live with that.
Do not, for any reason, consider altering or modifying your RV-3 or -4
airframe structure, unless you are or have direct access to an airframe
structural engineer. Even in that case it would be best if your engineer
was Dick VanGrunsven. (In the case of my construction of the RV-3, it was.
We have been close friends for years.) The typical builder will get
precious little help from any kit manufacturer until the rotary engine is
proven a viable replacement for the Lycoming. If the pioneers do things
right by producing clean installations that are functionally equivalent and
reliable, that time is coming.
I would not use the standard RV-3 or -4 cowl. First, the cheek cowls are
unnecessary and produce excessive drag to boot. (I know Nemesis is fast but
Sharp has the resources of the Skunk Works behind him.) Second, for weight
and balance purposes the engine should go forward a tad. I have already
noted to this group that the RV-4 has a tendency toward aft CG sensitivity.
This may mean a little more work for the first builder or two who makes an
attractive long nose, P 51 looking cowl. But I bet you could pull a mold
from it and sell copies. BTW this is the way the RV group has always
worked ---someone comes up with something that works and everyone else
needs, and a new business is started. I suspect the rotary engine group
will be the same. I could make a good short list of the things that need to
be developed right now.
With the engine forward for weight and balance, the water radiator can be
located between the engine and the firewall. Keep the engine and everything
associated with it where the engine belongs. Many of you builders seem to
grasp the concept that simpler is better when it comes to a home built
aircraft. One radiator is easier to mount, plumb, and baffle, than two.
Airflow through the vertical core is nearly optimum. (Paul hasn't run his
figures on that yet, but that is what he is going to find when he does.)
The radiator prices recently reported are very attractive. Straight
vertical flow is certainly available. The safety of only two water hoses
with four couplings total (versus radiators in multiples of two to four)
should not be ignored. Neither should the simplicity of maintaining the
desired engine temperatures (both cooling and heating) by way of a cowl flap
be ignored. I know that some who read and write here are struggling with
louvers, scoops, and various other band aid fixes, but it doesn't have to be
that way. We are all learning from those struggles.
The Rotary engine does accomplish a significant amount of cooling --- up to
1/3 of total cooling, some say. Thus efficient oil cooling is as important
as efficient water cooling. Some installations have used the standard,
readily available with same hose ends as the engine, Mazda oil cooler from
the RX-7. I might do the same at this point, and mount it transverse and
flat just forward of the top of the water radiator as I described earlier
for the Powersport RV-4 installation. Again, easy to mount, plumb, and
baffle. My oil cooler in the RV-3 was made by Circ of England as a racing
oil cooler and measured 14 by 12 by 2 in for a volume of 336 cubic inches.
That is over 5 times the cooler volume and about 10 times the plate/fin area
used on a 180 hp Lycoming.
The RV-3 or-4 builder will start with the fire wall and landing gear mount
portion of the engine mount from Van's Aircraft (that part can be ordered
without the dynafocal ring) and build forward the structure necessary to
support the rotary engine. As yet there is no consensus on the best tube
arrangement, type of isolators, et cetera. The last arrangement I had in
the RV-3 worked very well, and it used the factory mount points on the late
model (86-89) 13B engine, which made things easier. The only fabrication
was cups for conical mount rubber isolators. We still had a few other ideas
which we wanted to try, however, to simplify the tube structure.
Another totally undeveloped area is the exhaust system. I will say that for
most applications 321 stainless works fine for the primaries, the first
pipes out of the engine.. The trick is in making the first 12 inches in
three pieces ( it won't crack that way) and heavy enough to take the blow
torch (I used 0.125 wall here.) After the first 12 inches, and perhaps
sooner, you can go to 0.035 wall thickness with no problem. Most GA
aircraft use the thin stuff right out of the cylinder, but we have to
contend with the much higher EGT's of the rotary. Any silencer (muffler)
used on the -3 or -4 has to go under the engine and in front of the landing
gear structure so it has to be relatively flat. Paul Yaw seems to have some
dyno data on which cans might work best and I hope he will share that
information. Perhaps as development progresses he might be persuaded to
test on a rotary engine already on the dyno the tangential muffler often
mentioned on these pages. Everett Hatch had done a bunch of rotary engine
dyno testing on exhaust systems, He found a lot of things that hurt power,
nothing much really that helped, rather unlike the positive results from
exhaust tuning most of us are accustomed to. Intake tuning was much more
critical in the rotary where max power output and torque peak at the proper
rpm was concerned. Unfortunately, I believe that Everett's data has been
lost to us.
As Paul recently said, we are beginning to get a good handle on the
nitty-gritty of a lot of this stuff. (I don't think it is any way near the
"write a book "point yet.) He also noted that there is a lot more planning
in this than meets the eye. You have to know your weight and balance
picture before you start. Ed Anderson's weight and balance data was very
interesting, and, as presented, it works out all right. His engine
installation is a lot heavier than it seems like it should be. I would be
appreciative if Tracy Crook would share his data in the same way. You may
already have, Tracy. If you did, sorry I missed it --- would you please
repeat? It would be good if Jim could do the same. Thanks to both of you
in advance.
Please realize that I do not write in criticism of what anyone has already
done. Indeed, what was done yesterday is the basis for what we are going to
do today At the beginning of any endeavor there are lots of mistakes and
start-overs --- probably way more of those than successes The purpose of
this newsletter, or any newsletter for that matter, is to disseminate
information. How to proceed based on that information is the decision of the
reader.
Sorry this got so long. Some will find it useful. The rest of you, press
delete.