Subject: Rotary in RV-3, RV-4
From: Paul
Date: 3/19/1999, 8:47 AM
To: zz

Anderson Ed wrote:

Alan,
        A lot of good words and thoughts.  In my opinion, the combination on
this list of those who have the training/experience , inclination and/or
ability to to address the aspects of a topic from the more theoretical
point of view combined with those who (correctly or incorrectly) use
more of a back-of-the-envelop approach is invaluable. As most of us know
there can be a considerable difference between what initially appears to
be a theroretical best approach and what is feasible and practical.
Theoretical viewpoints are seldom (and should not be) constrained by
practical considerations.

Additionally, there certainly appear to be legitimate differences of
views on even the theoretical implications which if someone had the time
and $$ and would be so kind as to set up test situations with data
recording and analysis, we would undoubtedly be able to more quickly to
identify the most optimum solutions.  On the otherhand, when (or better
yet, IF) we reach the point where theory and experience have nailed down
the optimum solution for the rotary/RV airframe, I for one will find a
little of the challenge and thrill gone.  For me the journey has been as
much fun if not more fun than arriving at the destination.

For example, it appears that the "thins" win the theoretical contest
over "thicks" regarding cooling radiators.  However, in the real world,
it may be that the practical considerations may often result in the
"thicks" in an installation. Not because they are optimum from a heat
transfer viewpoint, but simple because they are sufficient, cheap (at
least [evaporator] cores out of junkyards), and simpler to configure.

Sort'a like the RV design.  It is not the fastest, not the best
areobatic, not the longest cross country range, not the best short
field, not the slowest stall, not the heaviest lifter, etc.,etc., but in
my opinion it is better in all the above categories than any other
single aircraft design around.  The point being that theoretically the
RV is not best in any single category, but is  optimum for a wide range
of conditions.

My 0.02

Ed Anderson


 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org