Subject: Rotary in RV-3, RV-4
From: Paul
Date: 3/19/1999, 8:27 PM
To: zz

Mike Wills wrote:

At 07:39 AM 3/19/99 -0800, you wrote:
Wrathall Mark wrote:


I think the big problem is that Dick hasn't (yet) built an RxV-7.
Aircraft are always a balance of compromises, and installing a water
cool rotary in the hole designed for an air cooled boxer isn't ideal.
It's a tribute to Dick and to Tracy, Ed, etc that the resulting aircraft
are still so good. If you know Dick personally, remind him that we need
an airframe designed around this powerplant.

Until this engine is proven by a lot of builders with lots of flying hours
there is going to be very little demand and consequently very little market
for an airframe designed specifically for this engine. So Vans has little
to gain and lots to lose by designing and marketing for this engine.
Perhaps if Everett had the opportunity to further refine his package things
would be a little different.

Sort of Dave Anders fast back RV-4 with a with a tapered wing. (I know
this is a pain, but only if you have to make each rib former. For a kit
manufacturer who already has the press, once the formers are made, it
should not be a big deal. Simplicity is good, but if you overdo it, you
end up with Volksplanes everywhere.)

Other than aesthetics, where is the gain in the tapered wing? The Mustang
II with tapered wing has little or no performance advantage at high speeds,
has poorer low speed performance, and poorer handling characteristics. The
constant chord wing is easier to build than a tapered wing; there is more
to building a wing than knocking out the formers. And for the tandem RVs
the wide constant chord wing provides the necessary cg range. There are
always compromises in aircraft design and few designers have come up with
anything as good at meeting the designer's (and the market's) goals as the
RV series.
 I cant believe that you are seriously comparing an RV of any type to a
Volksplane! Please identify any other kit on the market with fixed gear
that provides the kind of performance and utility of the RV series. Hell,
the fast glass guys have a hard time keeping up with some RVs in spite of
their fixed gear, fat wings, etc... Go back and read the cafe report on
Dave Anders RV-4, the highest scoring cafe airplane in history. And
remember that the airplane that it knocked off was John Harmons Rocket, an
RV derivative.

 I agree that an airplane designed from the start for this engine would be
an incremental improvememnt over a converted RV but that just isnt
realistic, the market to support such an endeavor is just not there. Until
it is we are gonna have to settle for converting existing airframes, and an
RV is a damn fine one to start with.

Mike Wills

Hey guys we don't want to get too carried away with "my airplane is
better
than yours" on here.

Paul Lamar.

 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org