Subject: Speed between RV6 and Rv4.
From: Paul
Date: 3/21/1999, 8:28 PM
To: zz

Tracy Crook wrote:

Paul wrote:

The only historical data we have on cowl cheeks suggests that the prop
works slightly better without them. I completely agree with you on your
RV4 frontal area argument. They add little to the overall drag.

As far as RV6 verses RV4 frontal area I would say that is worth close
to 10 to 15 MPH.

Given the difference in engines, Tracy Saylor's Rv6 is going 230 MPH or
so
while Dave Anders Rv4 is going about 250 MPH. Both have almost identical
air cooling systems and Dave has a fast back which he claims did not
help all that much. The rest of the aero tricks are the same.
Dave Anders has around 245 HP and I would guess, Tracy close to 200.
That HP difference alone should be worth around 10 MPH.
Paul Lamar


The only way to properly compare the two aircraft is to use Van's Aircraft
data on unmodified versions using the same engine.

>From his specifications we get:

RV-4   Top speed with 160 Lyc.  -  205 MPH   (loaded to 1160 lb)

RV-6   Top speed with 160 Lyc.  -  202 MPH   (loaded to 1240 lb)

A difference of only 3 MPH.   The small difference surprised even Van
himself who was reluctant to design a side by side version because he
assumed a much higher performance hit.

Tracy Crook
 rws@altavista.net

I can see why he was surprised.

I suspect the cooling drag of the Van's test Rv4 was higher than 
the cooling drag of the Van's test Rv6. There are other aerodynamic 
details between seemingly identical airplanes that make a difference 
in top speed  such as control surface gaps, air leaks, landing gear
strut
fairings, wheel pants, etc., etc.. Then too there could have been 
a difference in HP and props. 

Racers tend to know all the little go fast tricks and apply them.
They study each others airplanes very carefully.

I am willing  to bet the cooling drag and other aerodynamic details
of Dave Anders's airplane and Tracy Saylors airplane are much closer 
to each other than the details of Van's two seemingly identical 
engined airplanes.

When I see a 250 HP RV6 going 246 MPH I will believe that is really
the only difference due to frontal area.   

BTW Donald R Crawford rates the Rv4 with 202 MPH and an Rv6 at 175 MPH
both with 150 HP which is closer to the relative results Dave Anders
and Tracy Saylor are seeing. Both of Donalds RV's had the same gross
weight of 1500 pounds and he rates the wing surface area of the
RV6 at six additional square feet. The wing span is given as one foot
longer for the RV6.

Donald's book "A practical Guide to Airplane Performance
and Design" third printing revised  rates over 137 homebuilt airplanes, 
74 certified airplanes and 12 WW II fighter planes and his predicted 
numbers correlate very well with actual top speeds as given in Jane's
All the Worlds Aircraft and other sources.

I think Van needs to go back and check things out again on that fast Rv6
with 160 HP :-).

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org