Subject: Speed between RV-4 and RV-6
From: Paul
Date: 3/23/1999, 1:29 PM
To: zz

Mike Wills wrote:

At 09:07 AM 3/23/99 -0800, you wrote:
I am beginning to get clue on what is going on with the relative
drag of an RV4 verses RV6. It seems the prop situation comes
up more often than not. The optimum prop (pitch, diameter and
twist) for the two airplanes may not be the same despite
the use of the same engine. Don Bates always emphasizes
in his talks the importance of tayloring the prop to the
airplane. HP is only one of the factors.

The variable pitch prop installations have the advantage
of optimising the pitch for top speed of course.

Paul,
 From what Ive seen/read comparing stock RV6s and RV4s that are comparably
equipped engine wise, constant speed props still yields about the same
speed difference of 3mph, same as is true with fixed pitch props. I'd sure
like to believe that my -4 is gonna be faster than a comparably equipped -6
but the historical data doesnt support that. Just to add confusion it looks
like the RV8s with their larger frontal area(compared to a -4) and no
cheeks is also within a couple of mph + or - of the -4. Builder variation
(how straight was it built?) appears to cause more speed variation from
plane to plane, than which model you build.
 Its hard to get a good handle on the differences by comparing highly
modified RVs like Dave Anders' and Tracy Saylors'. As you pointed out there
are significant differences engine wise, and if you look at the details I
think Dave has gone a little further with the drag reduction details.
Better to compare airplanes that are stock built per plans.

Mike Wills

I think you are getting the "frontal area" term confused. It
is defined as the maximum cross sectional area of the airplane.
It occurs back around the highest point of the canopy or there
abouts. The frontal area of the RV8 and RV4 are about the same.
It is commonly misconstrued to mean the shape of the cowl.

I am still not convinced the speed difference between Dave's and
Tracy's is due to HP alone. That's is my whole point.
It takes cubed HP to go that much faster.

I spoke to Don Crawford and he told me the incorrect RV data 
came from Janes. Apparently Janes got it wrong so I ordered 
Don's programs and will run the corrected numbers. 

I will try small differences in HP's and prop eff's to see what affect
they have on top speed. I would do the same thing with Don Bates's 
prop program if it were not so expensive.

My ultimate goal is to see how well we are doing on cooling drag
reduction by judging from the top speed of the airplane.
  
Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org