Subject: Rataries compared to aircraft piston engines.
From: Paul
Date: 3/24/1999, 7:29 PM
To: zz

tom mayer wrote:

Paul,

 Another thing I'm confused about, but leery of addressing in
public, is this rotary weight business.  Tracy says in his manual, and
has written me, that his installation including everything but the
prop was 345 pounds.  I'm not an engineer.  I'm not even an A&P.  But
I've been around a BUNCH of Lycoming 0-320 installations on acro
planes, and 345 pounds is ballpark for a Lycoming 0-320.  What are
these guys who are coming in 100 pounds heavier than the Lycs doing?
What did Tracy do different, and, presumably, right?

    Yet another thing that keeps nagging me as I read all this
wonderful stuff.  Tolle, who certainly has beaucoup credentials, made
a big point of saying Tracy's accomplishments are admirable but he
never runs much at high power.  Tracy's recent newsletters, and some
of his postings on the site, suggest to me he's not only run an
impressive number of hours by now, a lot more than Tolle did, but that
since he got in the Fuel Controller business he's been developing more
power and using it at least some of the time, with no big engine
problems, at least so far.  Am I missing important points?

    In the weight and power questions I am being anything but
facetious.  If I stick a rotary on the Mustang I want it to run--I fly
over REALLY horrible terrain most of the time--and I want to blow it,
because most of the really horrible terrain I'm talking about is also
very high.  Reading Tolle after reading and studying Tracy with all
the care and attention I'm capable of I feel like a fellow who's
gotten a clean bill of health from one doctor only to be told by the
next chancre mechanic that his chances of seeing tomorrow are slim to
none.

    I wonder if I'm the only addict of your site with the same
questions.  You are obviously really knowledgable.  Perhaps you can
shed some light.  Thanks, Tom

The devil is in the details. Most auto-engine-in-airplane failures, 
if youread the NTSB  religiously like I do, you will discover
dumb stuff like wires falling off and oil lines breaking.
It is very important to pay very close attention to this 
kind of stuff. Those putting certified engines in airplanes
can check out the local Cessna and see how its done.
We have no such luxary.

>From my race car experience I would only use AN hose on
the cooling system. Once we did that our race car cooling 
systems became ten times more reliable. 

As far as the basic rotary goes I think it beats any piston
engine and that includes certified air craft piston engines
hands down in durabilty and reliability. Three moving parts,
no; camshafts, camshaft gears, poppet valves, valve springs,
fragile aluminum pistons subject to melting, rods,
piston pins, etc., etc., etc..

The rotary engine  eccentric shaft is a model of strength 
with hardly any stress concentrations at all compared to 
the stress concentration nightmare that is the crankshaft.

As soon as the aviation world wakes up to these facts, Mazda
rotary engines will be in high demand.

I would go for a blown rotary any day over a blown piston
engine. You will have to change certain materials in the
exhaust manifold and turbocharger turbine to Inconel
but it is not as expensive as you would think.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org