Subject: Rotaries compared to aircraft piston engines.
From: Paul
Date: 3/25/1999, 9:27 AM
To: zz

Anderson Ed wrote:

Tom,
   As Paul points out there are a number of installations factors that,
depending on your decision, will effect your weight.  There has been
some confusion about comparing apples and oranges regarding weight.
Alan initially focused on total aircraft weight which is affected by a
lot more than the engine installation. I doubt our engine installations
differ by more than 25-35 lbs if that much. Alan's installations had the
benefit of an extended and intensive development period by Everett Hatch
which none of the rest of use did.  Tracy clearly stated that his design
objective was to developed the least expensive installation he could
commenserate with his risk tolerance and I think he has done a superb
job of meeting that objective. I would have loved for Everett to have
written a couple of articles on his development, it would have probably
have moved the rotary movement further ahead. But, alas that was not to
be.

I, for one, used AN (stainless steel braided hoses) for all coolant, oil
and fuel lines.  The big AN-16 coolant hoses and AN fittings for the
radiators are heavy (and expensive), however, having had rubber hoses
split in automobiles, I was very adverse to having the same happen in my
aircraft, therefore my choice.  Also, due to interference with my motor
mount, I had to fabricate a homemade intake manifold.  My choice was to
machine intake runners in two 1 1/2 inch slabs of 10x12 aluminum bolted
together, which certainly added considerable weight over a "tube" type
intake manifold.  In hindsight, a poor choice from a weight standpoint.
Additionally, because I have a full IFR panel with (heavy) gyros, I
needed a vacuum source.  I elected to design a fitting that permitted me
to use an aircraft vacuum pump driven by a belt, which again added a few
pounds.  I had two 25AH batteries at 22 1/2 lbs each (again a little
over kill).  My motor mount is also in the overkill category more beefed
up and heavier than it needs to be.  My thickwalled exhaust headers
added some additional weight as did the two 8 lbs stainless steel
straight thru mufflers slung under the cockpit, etc, etc. In short, it
is very easy to just added a little thing here or there and soon the OZs
turn into pounds.

Another point to make is while almost all 320 -360 engine installations
with the same type prop weight essential the same, the total aircraft
weight between RV-6s may differ by 50 - 100 - 200 lbs.  I have seen the
weight of some 360/cs installations at over 1200lbs empty. So just as
with the use of certified engines the total weight is a factor of much
more than just your engine choice.

Tracy was very prudent in his initial cautious approach to opening up of
the engine performance envelop.  On the other hand, because Tracy had
several hundred hours of reliable operation on his engine when I took
to the air.  I felt Tracy had established the robustness of the rotary
for aircraft use and was therefore comfortable operating my engine at
max avaliable power within a few hours of the first flight.  In my 30
hours of flying thus far, my engine spends the majority of its time
operating above 5500 rpm. If its going to break, I want it to break
while I am in the test phase. I have flown for over two hours with the
engine running WOT (6000 rpm) with no adverse effects.  While there
appears to be a consenus that most autombile engines are not designed
and have questionable durability at long sustained periods at WOT
(unless modified for racing), this does not appear to be a constraint
for the wankel as proven in racing applications as well as Tracy's later
performance regime.

The basic bottom line is there is really nothing you need to do
internally to the rotary to give you reliable sustained high power
performance.  A number of reciprocating auto engines that are intended
to operated at sustained high power settings generally use race quality
parts which can add to the cost.  I believe Tracy's engine was right out
of the "junk yard" with a number of miles on it and it has given him
over 800 hours of reliable operation.

So Tom, we don't have all the answers, yet,  regarding the installation
of a wankel in an aircraft - but stay tuned. In my opinion you will not
find a better engine for reliablity and durability.  You read the
accident reports on reciprocating aircraft engines about thrown
connecting rods, burnt pistons, swallowed exhaust valuves, broken value
springs, spalling camshafts and piston pinons, fluttering piston rings,
cracked cylinders from shock cooling, broken cylinder studs, etc.,
etc., and you will soon come to conclusion that none of those things can
go wrong in a rotary because it simply does not have them.  Few parts =
greater relability!

Enough said, you may get the impression I am a rotary fanatic if I
continue {:>}.

Ed Anderson
RV-6A N494BW 30 hours of rotary power.


One of the purposes of this exchange between us rotary engine users is
so that other folks may benefit from the good, the bad, and the ugly.  I
have certainly gain a lot of insight and intend to redo some of my
choices - such as my boat anchor of an intake manifold.



Very elegant and well put Ed.

Thanks.

Paul




 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org