Subject: Rotaries compared to aircraft piston engines.
From: Paul
Date: 3/25/1999, 10:51 AM
To: zz

David Carter wrote:

David Carter interspersed comments to Tom Mayer's e-mail below:


tom mayer wrote:

 Another thing I'm confused about, but leery of addressing in
public, is this rotary weight business.  Tracy says in his manual, and
has written me, that his installation including everything but the
prop was 345 pounds.  I'm not an engineer.  I'm not even an A&P.  But
I've been around a BUNCH of Lycoming 0-320 installations on acro
planes, and 345 pounds is ballpark for a Lycoming 0-320.  What are
these guys who are coming in 100 pounds heavier than the Lycs doing?
What did Tracy do different, and, presumably, right?

        David comments:  Tom, I also saw Allan's comment about "rotary
powered RV's seem to be coming in about 100# heavier than . . ."  I simply
disregarded it and read all the e-mails on weight that followed.  Tracy's
math is good and there is no serious question about what the engine
installation, firewall forward, will weigh, in general.
         The subsequent rich exchange of info from many people simply
illustrated the few places where "engine and systems"  weight variations
can occur, for example, heavier radiator, heavier muffler, heavier exhaust
pipes, being the two main items.  The "conversation" then turned,
naturally, from focus on engine weight to other weight factors in the
complete aircraft.  There were a lot of things there.
        Bottom line, I would give Allan some "slack" and remember the context he
was using - he seems to have just had a slip of the "keyboard" when his
e-mail seemed to imply that the total aircraft weight variation was related
to using a rotary engine.  Really, all he was trying to do, if I can be
forgiven for speaking for him, was to encourage us to be weight conscious,
which thing he accomplished.  Allan nearly always highlights some
fundamental issues which we do well to heed.

    Yet another thing that keeps nagging me as I read all this
wonderful stuff.  Tolle, who certainly has beaucoup credentials, made
a big point of saying Tracy's accomplishments are admirable but he
never runs much at high power.  Tracy's recent newsletters, and some
of his postings on the site, suggest to me he's not only run an
impressive number of hours by now, a lot more than Tolle did, but that
since he got in the Fuel Controller business he's been developing more
power and using it at least some of the time, with no big engine
problems, at least so far.  Am I missing important points?

        David comments again, on "high power":  The way we mix multiple issues
into a single e-mail, with some items mentioned that are not related to the
"subject" line (not a  criticism) there is a tendancy to overlook details
that are posted in the many e-mails we submit to this rotary engine forum.
Again, in "defense" of Allan (excuse me Allan for doing this, but I thought
a "non-expert/regular new guy's" reaction might have merit), his main
context in relation to "high power" was "racing", as in the Sun N Fun 100
race, which he specifically talked about- successful completion of a race
is the ultimate, bragging rights, test of an engine and its cooling system.
 It might seem in later posts that he did not acknowledge Tracy and others
who have solved their cooling problems and can operate at high power for
normal takeoff and climb without limitations, meaning that they no longer
have to throttle back on hot days during climb to keep temperatures under
control.  To my knowledge, all those who have the most time have solved
their problems and no longer have to throttle back.  Now, takeoff and climb
is not racing, but that is what a satisfactory aircraft engine installation
has to do, as a minimum, to be "satisfactory".  I don't think there is any
doubt that the rotary is "satisfactory".

    In the weight and power questions I am being anything but
facetious.  If I stick a rotary on the Mustang I want it to run--I fly
over REALLY horrible terrain most of the time--and I want to blow it,
because most of the really horrible terrain I'm talking about is also
very high.  Reading Tolle after reading and studying Tracy with all
the care and attention I'm capable of I feel like a fellow who's
gotten a clean bill of health from one doctor only to be told by the
next chancre mechanic that his chances of seeing tomorrow are slim to
none.

        David, again:  I've been reading about turbos, with the ideo of
using one, since 1978.  Planned to turbo a 1835cc VW with controllable
pitch prop on a Vari-eze - finished the engine but never built the Eze.
I'm going get my RV-6 airborne with a rotary without turbo, to start with,
because that is good enough for a Gulf-coast sea level flyer.   I am,
however, interested in installing a turbo later for normalizing, so am
saving all the comments I glean from this forum.  I have seen nothing by
Tracy or Allan that would discourage one from turbo'ing a rotary.  I have
seen lots of others who ARE going to use turbos, so I don't think there is
a "mixed signal" there.  By the way, if you look at last page of Van's
"info pack" brochure, at the performance charts for the different models,
you'll see that the RV-6, at solo weight, operating at 10,000 feet MSL,
still has a 1000 feet per minute rate of climb.  That is better than a
turbo'd Cessna 172 or 182.  If your dream machine climbs anywhere nearly as
good as an RV-6, you may not really need a turbo.

 David Carter
   

The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org