Subject: The oil thing again & Mobil 1 with 100LL]
From: Paul
Date: 3/26/1999, 7:13 PM
To: zz

tom mayer wrote:

Paul,  Mike,
    As you know, av-gas still has substantial amounts of lead in it, even
100 low lead.  If I remember right, 100 LL has about the same amount of lead
as extinct leaded regular mo-gas.

    Several aircraft engine rebuilders I know tell me they can, or could,
easily tell on disassembly if an engine had been run with Mobil 1.  There
was lots of ashy sludge, an oil-soaked version of the light gray ash you
find in the stacks of any Lyc or Cont or P&W that's been leaned correctly
and is not burning oil.  Engines run on any mineral oil, ashless dispersant
or straight, or on a semi synthetic like Shell's, have a lot less.  I
believe the theory was that  the gray crap was plugging oil passages in some
of the high powered Continentals.

    I know no car engine rebuilders who regularly disassmble high mileage
car engines that have lived on Mobil 1.  It might be useful to find out what
some smart ground bound engine builder sees.

    I used Mobil 1 in an 0-320 Lyc that I got when it had 287 hours since
new.  The engine had taken almost 10 years to accumulate those 287 hours,
using Exxon Aviation Oil.  I flew it regularly.  Compression improved
substantially, and oil consumption went way down, from approx 7 hours per qt
to 12 or more.  I have no idea if that happened because I used the engine,
because I used Mobil 1 in it, or some combination, or none of the above.  I
ran av-gas and mo-gas in about equal amounts, sometimes mixed, sometimes
segregated in different tanks.

    That happy state of affairs endured for about 18 months,  until I got up
slightly past 1000 hours.  Compression remained excellent, but oil
consumption began to increase rather quickly.  I pulled the engine at about
1200 hours.  Monty Barrett, who took it on trade, told me he thought the oil
consumption was around the guides, that the engine showed very little wear
in most areas, and that it was exceptionally clean except for abnormally
high volumes of the gray sludge.  He would not speculate whether the sludge,
and,  by inference, the Mobil 1, had gotten to the guides.

    Monty Jr. told me that the overhauled engine was sold to a guy who used
Shell  15-50 in it, put it on some kind of trainer, and flew it to TBO, 2000
hours, w/o problem.  That may just mean the Barretts build better engines
than the Lycoming factory.

    I'm sure you know a bunch more about this than I do, but Aviation
Cunsumer and that guy who used to run Light Plane Maintenance both published
quite a bit suggesting even the Shell semi syn is not as kind to a Lyc or
Cont as a straight mineral or ashless dispersant.

    What, if anything, all of this has to do with what oil to use in an
airborne rotary I'm not sure.  But I think I'd use Mobil 1, if I liked it,
as long as I was running at least 75% of the time on mo-gas.  I think I'd be
real leery of it if I had to use av-gas most of the time.  (I doubt Mobil 1
is the best readily available full synthetic.  I did some pour tests with
Castrol Syntec 5-50 and Mobil 1, put 2 quarts in the freezer overnight, and
the Castrol poured out 20 seconds faster next morning.  I ran Castrol 5-50
for 25 hours in the Lycoming I'd been using Mobil 1 in.  The Castrol gave
slightly higher oil pressure at any given oil temp.)

    If and when I install a high powered rotary in something, I'll likely
use a lot of av gas.  I've seen too many fuel pressure gauges do vapor
pressure break dances running on mo-gas coming out of El Paso in July with
the OAT at 110, never mind that the airplane had a mo-gas STC.  If your
engine is blown and going to  high altitudes very fast the vapor pressure
menace is acute.
    What are the octane requirements of the rotary?  Are they as critical as
for a regular recip?

I think the rotray is much more tolerent of low octane gas.


    One other lubrication matter I haven't seen discussed.  I suspect
rotaries, like most aircraft engines, will spend a lot of time sitting,
compared to a car engine.  Need aircraft rotary users worry about things
drying out during weeks or months of inactivity? 

Water jacket corrosion is the big problem. The cooling system should be 
drained if allowed to sit for long periods.

If so, aside from Excedrin
headache preoiling systems, do you think there is an additive, like Lenkite
Av-Blend, that might be beneficial?  (The article posted on this site on the
uselessness of additives did not mention Lenkite.  I emailed them about it.
They can't be bothered to respond.  It sure seems to eliminate sticking
valves in Lycomings on sprayers, and using it to soak sticking or carboned
valves on on R-985s and R-1340s works better than using Marvel Mystery Oil.)

Might Lycoming's additive, LW-16702, be something to consider? (The article
made a big deal about no aircraft engine manufacturer recommending an
additive, which is patently not the case.)  Do you know, or does anyone else
know, what's in Lenkite and LW-16702?
    That's more like 5 cents worth.  Tom Mayer

 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org