Subject: Re: RV-4 versus RV-6 speed
From: Paul
Date: 3/28/1999, 11:42 AM
To: zz

Alan Tolle wrote:

Wow, that was quick.  I didn't any more press "send" than my last message
was sent back to me with your response, Paul.

My two aircraft which Van and I compared were equipped with identical
constant speed props, which I kind of thought optimized themselves.  I don't
think Bates propeller program has anything to do with it.  One aircraft
propeller was strobed on the other in flight to guarantee identical rpms.
Manifold pressure gauges were compared on the ground static and in the air
at WOT to determine error between them.  We do have to presume that the the
two instruments were linear at test data points in between.

Dick VanGrunsven is a pretty good engineer and he has done one hell of  a
lot of testing.  I grant that he knows what he is doing.

I can't accept using either Anders' or Saylors'  aircraft in comparison of
RV-4 versus -6 speed comparison.     There are just too many variables.
Both are far too modified from stock, and Anders is willing to punish his
engine.   The only accurate thing you can say is that Anders goes faster
than Saylors and both go faster than average.  We can speculate all we want
as to why the above is true.  I am not sure where that gets us in the rotary
engine development program.

For me the validity of the Kilo Trials is to demonstrate what builders can
do to enhance the performance of their aircraft.  I am not sure there was a
box stock bird in the bunch.

I have only one regret about Livingston's Kilo Trials.  I  live only 50
miles away, but no one bothered to tell me about the upcoming event when the
rotary engine was in the RV-3.  Do you suppose they were afraid of the
little 160 cubic engine giant killer?  It is possible.  Last time out over
the same course I   was only 5 mph behind Anders.  And gaining.  Maybe that
is why he went to the Venture airframe.

Come to think of it, I could do that too, with a stock 20B.

Perhaps this explains all the weird underlying  paranoi I get from Dave,
Keith, Tracy Saylor and other's in that crowd when I start talking about
the rotary. We really need to blow these guys off.

If you decide to build a turbo 13B or three rotor Allan let me know what 
I can do to help.
 
Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org