Here is an excerpt from the book Vee's For Victory
by Dan D. Whitney. 1998 Schiffer Publishing Ltd.
(610) 593 1771. Great book!
The design is similar to Everett Hatch's design in Allan
Tolle's RV3/RV4.
The comments about the over-hung gear affecting
the crankshaft do not completely apply to a rotary
as the eccentric shaft is much stronger and stiffer
than any similar size crankshaft ever could be.
"Reduction Gear Limitations
>From the beginning the power limiting component in the V-17 10-C
engine was the propeller reduction gear assembly. In the effort to
provide the maximum amount of streamlining, (and it was believed to
get the lightest reduction gear), Allison had utilized an "internal"
spur gear design driven by an "over-hung" crankshaft pinion. The
"driven gear" was set in a necessarily large diameter ring gear with
"internal" teeth. This in turn was supported by a large "plain"
bearing, fourteen inches in diameter. With the engine qualified to
run for short periods at up to 3700 rpm, the sliding velocity in
this bearing was an extremely high 13,561 feet per minute, or 154
mph. To keep everything working smoothly Allison directed almost 1/3
of the engine oil supply, at a pressure of about 75 psig, into the
bearing. Still it was enough of a concern that early development
engines were equipped with a bearing temperature indicator. If the
temperature increased abnormally it was time to significantly reduce
power and soon land. All of this meant that there was a limit to the
amount of power that could be reliably transmitted. The value was
set at 1150 bhp, though the V-17 10-19(C13) Hi-BHP test successfully
operated at up to 1575 bhp at 3000 rpm.
Allison was quite adamant about not overpowering the V-1710-C15
engine, stating that "on account [of] extreme overload on [the]
overhung pinion at the higher horsepower's involved" in operating at
takeoff manifold pressures up to the critical altitude of the engine.
50 The limitation was not the bearing, but rather the bending
stresses developed in the front cheek of tbe crankshaft as a result
of the high loads transmitted to the' crankshaft extension carrying
the pinion gear.
In early 1935 Wright Field asked Allison to investigate the
feasibility of designing a reduction gear with conventional bearings
for the engine. Such a unit was designed, and included provisions
for a bearing to support the outboard end of the crankshaft and
thereby eliminate the troublesome bending loads on the front
crankcheek. Unfortunately, considerable redesign of the engine would
have been required, including not only the new reduction gear
assembly, but significantly, new upper and lower crankcases, new
crankshaft, accessory drive system and considerable revision to
other detail parts. While the design was proposed for fitting to
the XJYV-1710-3. and XV-1710-5 engines, it was determined to not be
practical during the Type Test period. With the opportunity to
completely redesign the engine following the Type Test in 1937,
these features were incorporated in the "E" and "F" series engines,
which used straight cut "external" spur gears. As developed, the
E/F design followed closely the 1935 concept, and resulted in
lighter and more compact reduction gears than the original "C" gear
set. This created a higher "thrust line" that reduced frontal area.
Allison got their start in the engine business by building high
powered gearing and drives, and these reduction gears benefited from
all of that experience.
In September 1940 the Air Corps issued a Technical Order specific to
the early production V-1710-CID engines. It required inspection and
reworking of the reduction gears on overhauled engines that had had
any of their gears that mated with the large internally cut
reduction gear replaced. Allison was having trouble maintaining
tooth profile on the internally cut teeth. If galling or burring was
found, the fix required hand stoning of the damaged tooth faces
following by further running the engine, disassembly and
re-inspection. Evidently a similar procedure had been followed during
original manufacture an assembly of each engine."
allipsr2.jpg
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org