Subject: The wacko environmentalist are at it again.
From: Paul
Date: 5/1/1999, 9:01 AM
To: Allen Lyons CARB
CC: Don Sherman 2 <Dsherman12@cs.com>, Dennis Simanaitis <enged@aol.com>

XXXXX wrote:
Bill & Paul wrote:


Lot's of snips..........

I am not against clean air. What I am against is being treated like
a mushroom. Kept in the dark and fed shit. That is what the CARB/EPA
and Ford is trying to do to the car buying public with this OBD II crap.

It would cost Ford next to nothing to
output the OBD II diagnostic code to a cheap dashboard
mounted display. But NO! Ford arranged it so they and thier dealers
can make bigger bucks from the situation.
$85 to tell you what is wrong. $150 for a new
O2 sensor installed. $200 for a non adjustable mass air flow
sensor. etc., etc., etc.. Good luck trying to fix it
yourself. They are not about to tell you what the
computer is thinking and when. A simple software flow chart would
go a long way towards understanding what is going on and
how to fix it.

Here is a really nasty scenario. Since the program is in electrically
programmable and eraseable read only memory (EEPROM for short) it
is quite feasable for Ford to cause the program to fail based on 
a psuedo random mileage or a psuedo random time
forcing you to take your car to the dealer so only the dealer can download
a new program and replace the purposely sabotaged defective program.

Who could prove otherwise as the government allows Ford to keep
the program (and the codes necessary to download it) secret?
What safe guards do we have against this sceneario?

If the computer knows the left bank is too lean, and the plugs
agree, doesn't this prove that the 02 sensor is OK?? I am
assuming that the way the cpu knows that the bank is too lean
is that the 02 sensor is telling it.  Either the sensor is right and
the left bank is too lean, or it is wrong and the sensor is bad.
The plugs vote with the sensor, so I seriously doubt that it is
a bad 02 sensor.

The corillary is - Why in hell doesn't the damned thing *enrich*
the *&%$$#  mixture if it *knows* it is too lean!!!! If it has
FOUR (!!) 02 sensors it seems that it is designed to adjust the mixture
at least by the bank, and probably per every cylinder pair - depending
on where the four  02 sensors are located.

Let's see if I can make sense here:

There is a finite amount of adjustment that the closed loop control
and adaptive fuel strategy can do. When that limit is reached, a
code is set for lean operation.

The reasoning is that you can't just let it adjust forever. If it is
past a certain point, SOMETHING is wrong, and needs to be
fixed. Just throwing more fuel at it does not fix the problem.

There are only two sensors that control fuel. The two downstream are
to monitor the effectiveness of the catalytic converter.

Usually this code indicates a slow or failed O2 sensor. Other causes
are possible, such as an exhaust leak upstream of the sensor. In
between firing pulses a leak can draw in fresh air, fooling the sensor.
An intake manifold leak can cause one bank to read lean, too.

Of course, the above is based on logic, which may not apply
to EPA/CARB approved devices.   :-)

There is a lot of logic to these systems, but they are so complex
that it is often very difficult to understand why it does what it
does!

Thanks XXXXX. You seem to know more about these systems than
most. Do you work for Ford?

Yes.

I have Ben Watson's book How to
Tune & Modify Ford Fuel Injection and the complete shop
manual (over $100). Do you know of a better one on Ford 
OBD II systems?

I don't. I have not read any of the books out there. The in house stuff
is much better, but proprietary. I can't share it.

XXXXX

 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org