David Carter wrote:
David Carter askes:
Paul Yaw, did you really mean "replace both rotor housings" - regardless of
how they look? I thought you measured the housings and replaced only if out
of tolerance. ???
David Carter
<snip>
Paul Yaw responded (very well!):
Any engine that needs to come apart needs new rotor housings. The only
exception is a race engine which may come apart on a regular basis for
inspection. If the engine is in need of a rebuild, the rotor housings
have been garbage for a long time already. You will notice that they
all develop a small groove on the edges. The apex seal will have a
corresponding high spot, and so they fit together OK. If you put new
apex seals up against these old rotor housings, they will probably seal
worse than the old ones.
So, if you decide that the apex seals, and
rotor housings can be re-used, you are still screwing yourself. Let's
say for instance that you tear the engine down for a freshen up, at
50,000 miles. If it was well taken care of, the internals will probably
look quite good, which basically means that the engine should not have
been taken apart in the first place. But just for the sake of argument,
lets say that new rotor housings are good for 100,000 miles. If you put
the engine back together with the old housings, you have a 50,000 mile
engine.
So what is the point of building a 50,000 mile engine? This is
all just a long drawn out way of saying that if the engine needs a
rebuild because of excess oil consumption, low compression, or a water
leak, both housings are garbage. They wear quicker than the apex
seals. Mazda has what they call "rebuild" specs which are quite
different from what you would see in a new engine. What a bunch of BS.
about the only thing that can be re-used in a rotary engine is the
eccentric shaft, the rotors, the side housings if they are resurfaced,
and in many cases the stationary gears. These pieces show almost no
wear if the engine has been treated well, and besides, when was the last
time that someone had to rebuild their engine because the shaft, rotor,
or stationary gear broke?
Total cost for ALL new seals, new rotor
housings, and side housing resurfacing is about $1800. An engine built
properly will run at least 150,000 miles which works out to about 1.2
cents per mile. Re-using a bunch of parts that are within Mazda
"rebuild" specs will give you 50,000 if you are lucky. Most engines
rebuilt in this manner don't even last 30,000. Unfortunately the large
crowd of dipshit rebuilders that re-use garbage parts have promoted this
type of "rebuild"
Whew, I really got off on a rant there! The short story is that used
parts have already used up a good portion of their life span, so why
build an engine that is already half used up. If you have never rebuilt
a rotary, it will take you a long time. Why spend that time for
something that will not last long? If you have me build your engine,
you have no choice but to use all new parts because I refuse to build an
engine that is half dead when it leaves the engine stand. In other
words, If I rebuild your engine, I am going to put $1,100 dollars in my
pocket for labor. I will not take $1,100 dollars from you for
performing meticulous work on a bunch of garbage parts, and you wouldn't
want me to. Don't shortchange yourself.
I'm sorry if this sounds so abrasive. I have to explain to people on a
regular basis why my price is twice what Joe Schmo wants for a rebuild.
In many cases I recommend that if the customer wants to save money, that
they spend the $2000 on new parts and do it themselves rather than give
it to Jo Schmo who will assemble the engine from floor sweepings for the
same amount.
PY
Excellent educational erudition, Paul Yaw. Thank you very much for an
outstanding response. That is one of the best posts I've seen on this
e-mail newsletter system dealing with basic "need to know" stuff about
the rotary. No need to apologize for "abrasive" - didn't perceive it
that way at all. Thanks for sharing your experience with us "new guys".
My wife keeps asking why I spend so much time reading these engine
e-mails when I haven't even finished building my RV-6 airframe and don't
even have an engine, yet. This Paul Yaw feedback, and lots of other
good posts from lots of other good folks, is the exact reason I stay on
the list. Thank, all.
David Carter
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org