Paul Yaw wrote:
Paul wrote:
Paul Yaw wrote:
Lot's snips...
Any engine that needs to come apart needs new rotor housings. The only
exception is a race engine which may come apart on a regular basis for
inspection. If the engine is in need of a rebuild, the rotor housings
have been garbage for a long time already. You will notice that they
all develop a small groove on the edges. The apex seal will have a
corresponding high spot, and so they fit together OK. If you put new
apex seals up against these old rotor housings, they will probably seal
worse than the old ones. So, if you decide that the apex seals, and
rotor housings can be re-used, you are still screwing yourself.
Lot's more snips.......
PY
My theory on these grooves Paul is they are caused by two peice
seals. I think the short end of the two peice seal is pressed
against the rotor housing causeing the groove.
Because of smog problems Mazda had little choice but to
improve the low speed sealing. I maintain that a one peice seal
is better for high RPM heavy duty use such as found in an
aircraft engine. A one peice ceramic seal would not wear
anywhere near as fast as an iron seal and I suspect would
not groove the rotor housing such as you mentioned above.
Here is a graph from the Mazda Lemans engine SAE paper 920309.
As you can see the advantage of the ceramic two peice seal
is less than 2% at 6000 RPM and somewhat better than 2%
at 6500 RPM. To my way of thinking two peice or three peice
seals are not worth it for aircraft engines.
1v2seal.jpg
The "groove" appears on both sides of the rotor housing. As for the one
or two piece seal, I agree that if properly clearanced it is not a big
deal. A one piece seal does not groove the outside edges of the rotor
housing. I suspect that maybe the two piece seals rock back and forth.
The three piece seals are much better in this respect.
PY
The three peice look so fragile that I am kind of wary of their
use in aircraft engines. Particularly a turbo.
I am sure they seal much better at
low RPMs and the smog numbers are probably way better.
If you are down to 190 parts per million and the smog
spec is 170 parts per million I am sure you are forced
to do almost anything.
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org