Turrbie@aol.com wrote:
Due to the increasing number of emails that I have received lately regarding
Paul Yaw's statements about quality engine rebuilding, I feel it is necessary
to state my position to the group.
I agree with Paul Y that in an aircraft conversion, you should at least invest
in new rotor housings, lapped side housings, apex seals and seal springs.
Every used part (wearing parts) left in an overhaul could limit the engine's
life span. Since there are no hard figures for rotary's TBO in aircraft trim,
I would rather start with a fresh engine to be conservative.
However, I do disagree with Paul Y's figures on the life expectancy of a budget
overhaul. Granted, since there are high, low and 'service limit' tolerances
that an engine can be built to, the service life of an overhaul will vary
accordingly. The engines overhauled to Mazda's tolerances, in my experiences,
are very reliable.
My brother-in-law owned and raced an 1985 RX7 regularly in SCCA events. This
engine was built from 'Floor Sweepings' that were within Mazda's tolerances.
The car placed within the top five, three of the four years he raced
including three wins. The engine lasted four seasons, retired only because it
had out lived Phil, who died last June.
We all know of a certain rotary powered RV 4 that was placed into service
with nothing more than an overhaul consisting of: new apex seals, o-rings and
a gasket set. The engine conformed to Mazda's service tolerances when
assembled and is now approaching the 1000 hour mark. I cannot attribute this
to luck.
Throughout the past two and a half years, I have overhauled more than 27 13bs
following the methods I outlined in my video. I warranty them for 12 months
unlimited mileage. I have never had to warranty an engine or had a failure
outside of the warranty period, that I am aware of. The oldest one is
currently at 37,000 miles without incident. I advise all of my customers to
supplement the oil injection system with TWC III oil in the fuel.
Another reason for not building a Purist engine is simple economics. I have
two 87 RX7s, both featured in my overhaul videos. Neither of these cars are
worth more than $2500.00. So what sense would it make to install an engine
that is more valuable than the total car? Most of my customers are faced with
this same dilemma. Worst case, I think $1300.00 for a 50k motor is a real
bargain, especially considering the cost of replacing the car.
The 13b, in my humble opinion, is a bullet proof engine. It will handle a
tremendous amount of abuse and still continue to perform reliably. If there
was ever a glass jaw built on to the 13b, it was the automotive support
systems, most notably, the oil injection system. Since Mazda couldn't bring
itself to ask you to add 2 cycle oil to a sports car, they instead resorted
to injecting detergent oil into the fuel stream and rotor housings. This
compromise was further irritated by EPA's emission laws, forcing Mazda to
severely limit the volume of oil injected, dramatically decreasing the life
of the apex seals and rotor housings. This problem is easily rectified by
adding TCW III oil to the fuel during fill ups.
Again, I stress that an aircraft conversion should be placed in a category by
itself. The engine overhaul should be complete and without compromise on
quality. Build the best engine you can afford. As for other applications, the
cost / benefit curve for zero timed engines varies greatly.
Bruce Turrentine
Thanks Bruce. You really confirmed what I suspected about
mixed two cycle oil verses injecting system oil. I think these engines
will last nearly forever by mixing 2 cycle oil with the gas.
Good message.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org