JMLBlues@aol.com wrote:
In my previous life as a development engineer working on large diesel fueled
rotary engines, we ran Mobil Jet Engine Oil II (I think was the designation)
as metering oil. While seal wear was fine, the engine still had considerable
rotor and housing deposits, although perhaps of a different nature than with
standard mineral based engine oil.
Several caveats about the test and then my
theory:
First, we may have been over-oiling the engine.
Second, we were still
using mineral oil in the crankcase, and some mixing undoubtedly occured
because our rotor oil seals were not as good as Mazda's. My theory though is
that the synthetic oil is actually TOO GOOD at surviving the temperature
regime. What may have been happening is that the synthetic oil (a diester, if
I recall) does not have sufficient volatility. Thus, its residence time is
very long allowing whatever light ends are present to vaporize and leaving
the more temperature stable portions to slowly and steadily become oxidized
and form gunk.
Two stroke oils (even mineral based) may be better from a
deposit perspective because they are designed to do their job, disappear
cleanly, and be replenished on the next intake stroke. What were turbine oils
designed for? I think mostly to lubricate rolling element bearings in a
circulating, fully flooded moderately hot environment. I don't think they
were designed for sacrificial use in a combustion environment. Who knows???
Sounds plausible to me Jon.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org