Todd Carrico wrote:
Alfonso Lebron wrote:
Very interesting if the primary aero. activity is not racing.
Quick low-end boost should be important in aborted landings.
Probably less chances of something catching fire inside the cowl.
Probably cheaper and less components.
Arguments on the contrary? What type of supercharger?
Would be interesting to hear you opinion.
Alfonso Lebron
You are going at least 60 MPH so low end is not needed in
a go around situation. You would be better off spending your
money on a variable pitch prop. Rootes blowers have many
drawbacks. They are way less efficient than centrifugal
blowers and they sap energy from the e shaft so fuel
consumption will be higher. Not what you need with a
rotary. The low efficiency is manifest in hotter intake
air so boost must be modest or an effective intercooler used
or detonation will result.
For an aircraft I would stick with a turbo charger and
intercooler.
Car and boat perhaps a rootes.
I believe the Paxton is centrifugal, and would be my choice if
all I wanted was "some" boost.
Overall, a turbo will be more efficient due to the fact
that the energy required to operate it is waste energy.
The turbo compound concept is probably the most efficient.
Although probably the most development intensive.
Belt drive superchargers require usefull torque of course.
A paxton would be simpler to install, maintain, and operate,
as long as you did not mind the fact that it was not the most
efficient. It would make decent power, and you could make
a waste gate that would effectivley act as a normalizer. This
would remove the need to for a constant speed prop to get all the
benefit.
my $0.02
tc
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org