Paul Yaw wrote:
The only drawback that I see is the power required to drive the unit
itself. As for efficiency, the Paxton and Vortech (Centrifugal blowers)
have numbers similar to a good turbo. On the subject of compressor
efficiency, most turbos are very poor at low boost pressures, and
improve at higher pressure ratios. If you are interested in this, you
can see several compressor maps at www.turboneticsinc.com. The fact is
that boost is never free. The exhaust backpressure caused by a turbo is
detrimental to horsepower, efficiency, and engine longevity.
PY
I agree the efficiency of the mechanically driven centrifugal blower
itself is the same as the turbo driven centrifugal blower both at the
same
pressure ratio and RPM level. There is no question that a turbo
gives better BFSC than a mechanical driven centrifugal blower.
Don't forget the in-efficiency of the gear/belt drive.
Turbos are better at self-regulating as well. When power is needed
it is automatically supplied. While the mech blower goes along for
a free ride.
As far as boost not being free on a turbo.
Yes but to what extent? In some case the back pressure may be
benificial in regard to valve overlap. I agree the cooling load
is much higher and the load on the main bearings is higher but
the load on the rotor bearings is lower. I think we need to
quantify the situation. There is no question in my mind that
the waste heat load of super is higher than a turbo for a given
amount of HP out. HP per pound is a strong issue in aircraft
engines.
It is a complex question.
The real free lunch, if there ever was one, is the simple
exhaust turbine where waste heat energy is fed back into
the e-shaft only. Typical numbers are 20% more power
with no additional load on the bearing, apex seals
or cooling while the fuel consummed is the same.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org