Paul Yaw wrote:
Paul wrote:
We are slowly getting some numbers on super verses turbo.
Jon's 22 HP for the supercharged 240 HP engine is the
first example.
Here is an interesting chart of back pressure verses
MEP for both peripheral and side ports. MEP is proportional
to torque and HP at a given RPM.
If we take the side port data it takes six times more
back pressure to affect the power 12.5%.
Now all we need are some exhaust pressures from Paul Yaws
turbo charged 250 HP 13B with and with out the turbo
and we might have a rough handle on how much power
Paul Yaw's turbo is saping from the engine.
I did monitor manifold and exhaust pressure, but we did it manually with
a dual manifold pressure guage. I have already ordered the pressure
transducers to tie this in with the DePac. NEXT time it will be
datalogged.
So, from memory:
2000 rpm mp=31 ep=31,
4000 rpm mp=36 ep=33,
5000 rpm mp=40 ep=37,
6000 rpm mp=41 ep=38,
6300 rpm mp=43 ep=40,
6500 rpm mp=43 ep=43.
That is from memory, so it is not all that
accurate, but I do remember clearly that until about 6400 rpm the
exhaust pressure at the turbo inlet was 3" below the manifold pressure.
If you would like to see an illustration of the effects of backpressure,
look again at the spreadshhet data that I sent you. Right at the end of
the run when the exh. pressure caught up with and then finally exceeded
manifold pressure, the VE continued to rise, but the torque actually
dropped off slightly. This is a very minor change, but it repeated on
previous passes as well.
BTW According to this chart peripheral ports are very
sensitive to back pressure yet a turbo charged peripheral
port engine can generate 300 HP per rotor at 7500 RPM.
The turbo charged three rotor engine currently on Racing
Beat's dyno is that type of engine and is generating
those kinds of numbers.
In terms of predicting horsepower based on manifold pressure, the
important thing is the pressure differential between the intake and
exhaust. In the charts, they show the effect of increased backpressure,
but I believe it is more instructive to consider it in terms of the
differential between the two. This is especially true in the case of a
peripheral, or bridge which has a great deal of overlap. The turbo
engine would have benefited (How do you spell that?) from an increase in
overlap, but it also could have increased the EGT's if it got to the
point of blowing fuel out the exhaust.
A motor with a great deal of
overlap will make tremendous amounts of power if the exhaust pressure
remains less than the manifold pressure. If the opposite happens you
will lose power in a BIG hurry. This is not as critical with a standard
side port engine.
PY
Thanks Paul. I assume those are inches of HG so I will have to
convert to mm of HG. I am a little too sleepy to do it tonight
despite my late afternoon nap :-)
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org