JMLBlues@aol.com wrote:
I feel that the subject comments require amplification. My thoughts on the
topic are:
1. The synthetic basestocks may be "clean burning," but what happens to them
before they burn? The lubricant will be on surfaces for which temperatures
are too low for combustion of the oil, but high enough to promote slow
oxidation and thermal breakdown. This situation may lead to thickening and
deposit formation. To avoid deposits in a rotary, the lubrication system
should be optimized in terms of the delivery quantity per time balanced by
the volatility and stabililty of the lubricant.
2. Zinc is added not only as a "last ditch" before the thick film
hydrodynamic lubrication regime breaks down due to poor oil performance. Many
systems function only because a boundry lubricant exists. Remove the zinc
from a conventional oil (in a piston engine) and wear rates will go up even
with the best basestock. Especially with a new engine, there are microscopic
high points (asperities) on rings and liners which are protected from welding
and tearing (scuffing) by boundry lubricating films which are promoted by the
zinc additive. Also, microscopically, temperature excursions caused by
friction create asperities which require zinc constantly. Camshafts and
tappets function in the boundary lubrication zone frequently and require
appropriate zinc additives to avoid rapid wear. This is also true in diesel
injection pumps. Highly stressed gear teeth (diesel camshaft drives) require
so called "extreme pressure" or "EP" additives -- zinc. Finally, ash deposits
from metallic additives (zinc, calcium, and magnesium predominantly) require
very high temperatures to form -- around 700 deg F or so. You'll see these
temperatures only on spark plugs and poorly cooled rotor in the combustion
recess. Ash deposits are light incolor (tan or white) and very hard compared
to the more common carbonaceous deposits formed by the basestock degradation.
email: j.lauter@rotarymarine.com
Jon Lauter
Rotary Power Marine Corporation http://www.rotarymarine.com/
Good post Jon. Thanks.
BTW Got any pictures of that river boat hauling logs in BC CA with three
of your engines? I am facinated with that project. You should put them
on your web site as well.
BTW HTML tip: make your web site address as part of your "signature"
in Netscape or MS IE as above.
Do you mind my adding a link to your web site on the ACRE NL web site?
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org