Subject: Turbines for all?
From: Paul
Date: 5/31/1999, 8:48 PM
To: zz

Bill Freeman wrote:

Paul,

My final comments on the T Luscombe.   First, please remember
the old saw "Every airplane is a collection of compromises
flying in close formation".  Much more so than any other device,
if you change one aspect of the design of an airplane, you will
cause SERIOUS repercussions in at least one, and usually two or
three other aspects.  Usually, the landing speed is the fist
casualty, since it is the keystone of the whole design.

So - trim the wings of the Luscombe from 35 ft to 23 ft.   I
estimate a 10 mph stall increase, at least - assuming the same
weight.  With 54 gallons of fuel, plus tanks, pumps, and even
allowing for a lighter engine, I guess maybe 200-300 lbs added
to the gross weight.  This is probably another 5-7 mph on the
stall speed. We are starting to infringe on our survivability in
the event of an off airport landing, while at the same time,
increasing the probability of one being needed.

[Crash energy is mass times velocity SQUARED!!! Paul]

Also,  was the 16 gph fuel flow figure quoted for the 172 mph
cruise, or as usual, quote the top speed for cruise speed, and
low cruise fuel flow?  Not accusing the Luscombe people, and do
not intend to offend, but this is nearly SOP with performance
figures.  Sometimes it is caused by article writers taking
things out of context.  I am suspicious of ANY Luscombe that is
going 172 mph; these things have VERY draggy designs, plus what
of flutter?  Ailerons and elevators are usually NOT mass
balanced on these low speed birds, and 172 mph is a whole
different world - flutter-wise.
Again,  I don't mean to rain on anyone's experimental joys, but
the laws of physics WILL be strictly enforced, and lets be a bit
more skeptical out there.  If it seems too good to be true, it
probably is.  No cow magnets on the fuel lines or 200 mpg carbs
out there, please.  OTOH, lets keep an open mind for new things,
ask a few polite questions about new ideas and be ready to learn
or if necessary, shake our heads and walk away.  If someone has
a new slant, what is the breakthru that enables it?

Perry's ducted fan is a good example.  Many reasons why it could
be inefficient, but he has done a lot of homework, has a good
reason why it might be advantageous in this case (eliminate the
PSRU, maybe at an acceptably small loss of efficiency), has
studied the available technical literature and will give it a
careful try.  With eyes open, and sound study, this is good.

IMHO, the current best shot at a "cheap" turbine engine (a VERY
relative term) is the Williams fanjet under development.  After
some discussion with Burt Rutan, and a few other folks, plus a
look at a new EXTREMELY innovative tank APU, there ARE some new
ideas that can drastically reduce the cost of turbines, within
the laws of physics (& economics).  One of the big things is the
near elimination of gears to drive a (normally) raft of accys
(see Jeff Spitzer's comments on AGMA class 12 gears -$$$$) by
running all accys at shaft speeds, and using air bearings.
Starting and generation is by permanent magnet brushless
electronically controlled motor/generator.  Affordable high
power solid state electronics is an enabling technology, along
with high power permanent magnets, couldn't have happened 10-15
yrs ago.  The only gears may be in the fan drive.

OTOH, some think the Williams engine is gov't sponsored
vaporware.  We'll see.

SO --- The rotary is much more likely to be a near term
affordable AC engine with acceptable fuel burn than a converted
APU.  One man's opinion.


Bill


The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org