Wschertz@aol.com wrote:
In a message dated 5/31/99 23:57:05, Paul wrote:
I thought some more about removing the bulkhead behind the front
seats and replacing it with a longitudinal beam incorporating
the console to take the bending loads and I think it is the way to go.
The bulkhead in question is the double U shaped thing just behind
the front seats. It interferes with traditional adjustable seats
such as Geo Tracker seats.
As you can see in this picture the center console stops short
of the firewall. I also think the rudder pedals will have to be
moved closer together to make room. Another advantage is it will beef
the firewall where the high loads go in from the front gear without
adding
much weight. There will be some additional plys on the inside of
the fuselage to distribute the compression load from the spars
into the fuse structure but these could be only several layers
of carbon fiber.
What do you think Bill?
If I recall, the console running down the centerline of the plane on the
floor is removable behind the rear seat, therefore cannot be structural. The
"pillar" behind the front seats is structural. Bringing the center console
forward to the firewall would strengthen the firewall at the expense of
access to the hardware (rudder cables, flap handle, fuel valves, etc.
There clearly is room for the radiators behind the baggage compartment. The
NACA ducts would have to start AFT of the rear wing spar. I question the
accessibility for maintainance/removal of the rads in that location, (can you
say working on your head in a tunnel?) but otherwise it would work fine.
I am still not convinced that there is not adequate room in the cowl for the
rads, with the associated plumbing being shorter. I still have some time, as
I am still closing out the second wing.
It is true the making it structural would also make it more difficult
to gain access but the two side walls are low stress so large holes
could be incorporated for access. It is basically a box beam
with little or no torsional load so the top cover is the main
tension load bearing member. We are talking about three or four layers
of uni carbon cloth. The rear removable part could be bolted to
the sides with 10-32 machine screws and nut plates and still
carry a lot of bending load. In fact this goes for the front
part as well. The screw spacing could be as much as four inches
I would guess.
As a really rough estimate of the stress I will assume a front
point load on the beam of 4 G's times 500 pounds or 2000 pounds
and the firewall is 50 inches ahead of the spar.
The bending moment on the beam would then be 100,000 inch pounds.
This assumes the entire weight of the structure forward of the spar
including everything under the cowl is concentrated on the end
of the beam. This I think is very conservative scenario.
It ignors the contributions of the fuselage sides. It is also
one fifth the gross weight of the airplane however most
of the load is centered on the spar. Wing weight, fuel load, pilot
and front pax. The bending load from the motor mount is taken by the
upper longerons and the floor. The resulting engine shear load is then
assumed concentrated on the end of the beam at the firewall.
If it is ten inches high the tensile load in the top is 10,000 pounds.
If the carbon layup is .040 thick and five inches wide that would give
us a tensile stress area of 0.2 square inches. The tensile stress would
then be 50,000 psi which is nothing for uni carbon fiber. Hand layed uni
directional e-glass will take 40,000 psi. There are some holes in the
top of the beam but they could be doubled up. The max stress is directly
over the spar but the layers can be tapered as the beam gets closer
to the firewall and the aft bulkhead. The sides of the beam in the
spar area also need to be beefed up to take the compressive loads.
As usual what really matters in structural design is what is connected
to what and the geometric details. The floor is more likely to buckle
The best part is there would be little weight increase as the console
is already there.
With regards to Mark's plane for sale, didn't Mark make an extended fuel bay
in one of the bays behind the spar? If so, there would be access through the
filler door for inspection of the wing construction quality. Also an
ultrasonic tester could be applied to the joints to test for voids if that
was what you were worried about.
Bill Schertz
Yes he did. That gave some access.
As I understand it an ultrasonic tests cannot tell the difference
between pure resin and cloth filled resin or chopped fiber filled
resin. It has been years since I used one so perhaps the technology
has improved. I think it would be a more accurate test if you had
a known good wing to compare it too. The coin tap test appears
to be as good as an ultrasonic test for discovering out and out
voids.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org