Jeff Spitzer wrote:
Paul Yaw wrote:
snips............
3. I contend that the apex seals are cooled through their contact with
the rotor housing which is water cooled. For this reason, I want to
avoid hot spots on the housing surface. My contention is that
increasing the premix oil does not COOL the apex seals. It does however
allow them to run cooler because of reduced friction.
Paul Lamar replied:
I think you are wrong about this Paul. I have several Mazda papers that
have measured apex seal temps as a function of the amount of
apex seal oil injected. The primary function of the oil is to
cool the seals. The lube film would limit the apex seal heat
transfer anyway. The housing surface near the plugs is probably
almost as hot as the apex seal so there would be little heat
transfer. Housing surfaces run 180 C or 350 F while the apex seal is
as much as 500 degrees F at its center. Right around the leading plug
holes
surface temps run 210 C or 410 F. This is without grooving. Two cycle
oil should handle that fine without coking. These numbers are WOT 6000
RPM. IMHO the coking is caused by injecting poor quality system oil.
Grooves can't hurt of course but they probably reduce the
BSFC slightly. PL sealtemp.jpg
Jeff Spitzer chimed in:
I don't dispute the
chart that was attached, just PL's interpretation. The apex seal is
operating in a boundary lubrication mode. The friction and heat
*generated* at the apex seal boundary is a strong function of the
characteristic of the film. The reason why apex seals run cooler with more
oil is because they generate less heat IMO. There is probably heat
transfer in all directions from/to the apex seal throughout the cycle. As
the seal passes over the plugs it may pick up heat from the housing. The
seal will most certainly pass heat TO the housing on the majority of the
cold sections of the engine. The same goes for seal to rotor.
Paul Yaw continues:
So, since I don't know anything about heat transfer, is there a better
way to cool this area? Is there anything more that can be done?
I have noticed that engines which have been modified in this manner
color the spark plugs differently. The ceramic will be slightly darker
in color which shows that more heat is being pulled into the water
jacket.
Now I wonder if something more can be done. Any takers?
Also, Jeff Spitzer, could I get your e-mail address? I would like to
ask you some questions about cavitation, and the stock water pump.
Jeff Spitzer (spitze@gat.com) wrote:
Assuming no big changes in configuration or coolant, two things are good to
keep a high flux area cool.
1) get the coolant closer to the hot surface
2) increase the heat transfer area. The grooves seem to be a reasonable
attempt to do both. I think they have a defect though. The *turbulence*
that is generated is a result of flow separation of the backside of the
groove walls. This is probably better than nothing because it draws cooler
fluid down to the surface. The downside is that the backside itself is
pretty useless for heat transfer and is probably nothing but a little
localized vapor pocket. If I were going to do something and knew nothing
of what had been done, I would have aligned the grooves more with the flow.
I think a nice chevron type pattern of vortex generators would move the
vapor away from the surface (into the vortex core) and actually increase
flow velocity along the surface due to vortex rotation. This is, of
course, much more difficult to machine but if you're doing it by hand maybe
not.
I sure would like to see the test results on this one. If PY is
really interested, we could learn alot just by cutting the outer wall off a
dead rotor housing, replacing it with plexi and observing the flow in a
grooved section powered by a garden hose. I have a rally neat die
injection technique I could share with you.
Jeff Spitzer
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org