Vance and Emily Jaqua wrote:
Paul Lamar wrote:
This is a vertical section through Perry Micks ducted fan
on the back of his EZ.
It is a good example of why one cannot consider just the mass
flow through the fan when estimating the thrust.
The large radius lip on Perry's duct generates a thrust
on its own from the air flowing over the large curved
surface. If you add up all the little T1 components
of the pressure vector V2 you will get the thrust
>from this pressure distribution. One can verify this, as I have, by
holding your hand on the outside of the duct and noticeing
a forward airflow around and into the duct.
Unfortunately this effect is partially
canceled in Perry's application by the large hump in the
cowling to enclose the stock intake manifold. I will have
some pictures of this later today. As you can see in sketch
A the drag component of vector V1 added up will partially cancel
the thrust components of vector V2.
At high speeds however the large lip becomes a liabilty
as dynamic pressure over comes this effect and the direction
of the pressure vectors is reversed and the drag components
become dominate. However the cowling pressure situation is more or
less the same and the vector V1 does not change direction so
these drag components merely continue to add drag to the
airplane.
This is why I state Perry Micks duct is a low speed duct
and why one cannot ignore the drag of the duct when
calculating the thrust. One must take into consideration
the added drag of the duct when estimating the thrust at
high speeds. In the extreme if you add x amount of
thrust to a small diameter prop by enclosing it in a duct
and you also add x amount of drag. You have achieved nothing.
You are still stuck with the low efficiency of the small
diameter prop. Further more you are also stuck with the
excess weight of the duct.
However at low speeds this kind of duct may show advantages.
Paul Lamar
The more you write about this, Paul, the more I see that you have studied
ducted fans at some length before accepting the conventional wisdom. Kudos
for that. Too bad the conventional wisdom was not in favor of the duct :-(
Jeff Spitzer
Why thank you Jeff. Coming from you that is a great complement :-)
Paul Lamar
Vance wrote:
I can never decide which end of the letter to put
my 2 cents in - but here goes. I wish this project
the best - but have reservations as apparently
others have as well - The current issue of Contact
Magazine has a very good article on Pushy Galore,
which started as Texas Gem with a rear duct later
removed - also some good comments on the effect of
"bluff body" impact on closely mounted - small dia
props. The duct may help reduce those if configured
properly. Also the use of a Warp drive prop with
pretty well proven high rpm durability and the
advantage of adjustible pitch might be worth
considering - good luck and thanks for keeping
us updated. - Vance
I think the Warp Drive blade might be ideal for a fan as one can
grind or sand on it without dire consequences as all carbon fibers
run in the axial direction. This too is its weakness
as it tends to soften and fail near the hub when used on a 360
cubic inch four cycle four cylinder aircraft piston engine due to
torque reversals. This of course would not be a
problem with the much smoother rotary.
Grinding the blade tips down to make a transonic fan tip airfoil would
destroy what little torsional stiffness the blades currently enjoy.
Perhaps a layer of fibers re-applied over the ground down ends
at a 30 degree angle would restore some torsional stiffness.
A transonic airfoil near the fan tips might be the key to get
the ducted fan to work better. A supersonic induced shock wave
on the top of a subsonic airfoil would act like a brick wall
as far as higher RPM and more power are concerned.
A variable pitch hub would also allow one to test the blades
at high RPM on the ground. This is not possible with a
fixed pitch fan as the fan is limited to some static RPM
well below peak power and RPM. Consequently there is a risk of losing
a blade if the airplane achieves a speed in the air where the
engine can reach max RPM.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org