Jeff Spitzer wrote:
Perry Mick wrote:
Sounds like you've had some "hands on" experiences with these things.
Can you tell us more about what you did, problems you had.
I designed several ducted fan propulsion systems while at Moller. I'm
sorry to say that I don't see a lot of study or forethought in your
aerodynamic design. The engine is blocking way too much of the "fan". The
fan is not a fan but a propeller. The efficiency of a ducted fan is HIGHLY
dependent on uniform inflow. You will not obtain uniform inflow with your
small hub radius and large bumps. Every ducted fan designer faces the same
problem. The best compromise is to use a large ratio hub. I'm not up to
speed on the aero of the fan but I believe there is actually a "best" point
at around 50%-60% hub to tip radius.
If you do this to your package you
will have to use more blades in order to get the proper CL. Typical ducted
fans have many blades for this reason. A number like 8 might be about
right. Another advantage of more blades is cascade efficiencies. More
blades allow you to run higher pressure ratios further improving the
efficiency of your duct. Note, BTW, that I'm not suggesting lower mass
flow. The velocity through the duct will go up. Efficiency is related to
many things and low speed flow is hard to pressurize properly in a fan. It
appears that your duct is designed *only* for static thrust and not even
very good for that. I don't think you're going to get any kind of speed
out of this thing.
A proper ducted fan works off a pressure rise theory
different from a propeller that has a slipstream. It appears that your
duct is trying to approximate a slipstream entry but I have no explanation
for the divergent nozzle. A ducted fan in static conditions will make more
static thrust due to lip suction if the exit area is similar to fan area.
I talked a little about this in my previous post. If the exit area is
smaller (nozzle) then the duct will be more effective at higher speeds. I
have never heard of a duct getting larger at the exit. Your system is not
hopeless but I really think you need a bigger hub and more blades.
Further, the blades must be designed as FAN blades and incorporate uniform
inflow twist and chord distributions. I really don't have time or interest
in debating this or educating myself or anyone else on the pros/cons of
ducted fans. Let me say that I worked on them enough to have an opinion
where they belong and it is the same as PL's.
Ducted fans are better if:
1) You need high static thrust in a confined space (otherwise a helicopter
rotor is better)
2) You are going at high subsonic speeds. Otherwise a
prop is just plain always better. I think your effort to eliminate the
PSRU will be many times what it would take to *build* a PSRU. I'm sorry to
be so negative but you asked.
Jeff Spitzer
Perry has a six bladed fan that he built prior to this one. A false hub
made from
foam and fiber glass could be constructed to achieve Jeff's suggested
ratio
of hub diameter to tip diameter of 50 to 60%. It would make streamlining
the
engine much much easier as Jeff also suggested.
However I think this improvement should be made after the flight test
shows
some promise. I also think making the blades thinner at the tips should
be a higher priority.
IMHO that too should wait until after the first flight test.
I think it will fly with a little help from a quick shot of emergency
HP.
BTW Perry make sure you have enough for at least a minute as you need
to climb that long to get situated for a safe landing.
Perry is on his second duct and his second fan. I would hate to
encourage him
by suggesting yet another duct and fan are indicated and then have them
not meet his expectations.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org