Subject: Rotary verses the piston aircraft engine.
From: Paul
Date: 6/24/1999, 9:36 PM
To: zz

JMLBlues@aol.com wrote:

Paul,

As one whose fortune is tied to rotary engines, I'd still like to
respectfully interject a bit of realism into the fray. A 13B at 730 hp is NOT
a reliable powerplant. Better perhaps than a piston engine stretched as far,
but still not a reliable engine. One must also wonder if a 730hp 13B is too
finely tuned for top end power to be of much use without a 10 speed gearbox.
Finally, I am very skeptical about the power claims that some people make. An
instantaneous dyno point using dry ice to cool the intake charge and then
applying outdated correction factors to the raw data do not make for a real
engine.

No question about it. I was just using that as an example of the reserve
structural strength inherent in the rotary. In the case of Able Ibara
I have no doubt the engine will generate 730 HP for 8 seconds as I have
examined his stock steel body car and do believe it weighs 2000 pounds,
goes 165 MPH in less than 8 seconds in the quarter mile. Something is
pushing it along :-) PL


Having also worked on the 2000 lb variety of piston engines (at Cummins, as
an engineer working on the 11 liter class eight truck engine), I can tell you
that they are designed to acheive remarkable efficiency (BSFC of 0.30!) and
often run 800,000 miles before an overhaul. We had some field test trucks
returning 8 mpg hauling 40,000 lbs loads. I have no aircraft engine
experience, but I would guess that it is not worth the substantial investment
to make a newly optimized aircraft piston engine due to the rather small
market. If such an effort were to be undertaken, I believe that power to
weight ratios approaching the stock 13B could be acheived, with good
reliability. We should also recognize that as good as the 13B is, it is not a
weight optimized engine -- iron end housings could easily be aluminum, the
crank is too heavy, and with very serious effort lighter rotors could be
made. The target for a modern rotary should be better than 1lb / hp, not
close to 2 lb / hp.

Respectfully yours,
Jonathan Lauter


The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org