Subject: Rotary verses the piston aircraft engine.
From: Paul
Date: 6/24/1999, 11:08 PM
To: zz

Paul Yaw wrote:

Paul wrote:

JMLBlues@aol.com wrote:

Paul,

As one whose fortune is tied to rotary engines, I'd still like to
respectfully interject a bit of realism into the fray. A 13B at 730 hp is NOT
a reliable powerplant. Better perhaps than a piston engine stretched as far,
but still not a reliable engine. One must also wonder if a 730hp 13B is too
finely tuned for top end power to be of much use without a 10 speed gearbox.
Finally, I am very skeptical about the power claims that some people make. An
instantaneous dyno point using dry ice to cool the intake charge and then
applying outdated correction factors to the raw data do not make for a real
engine.

I have heard the "outdated" correction factor argument many times.  The
argument is that the later correction factor (J1349, J1985) is more
accurate than the early correction factor (J607).  The fact is that
correction factors should be called correction educated guesses.  They
simply are not accurate, but they are the best that we have to make
comparisons when engines are tested under different atmospheric
conditions.  They do not take into account that temperature, and
humidity will affect flame speed differently in different engines.  That
is just one of the many things that it cannot take into acccount.

Someone using the early correction factor on their dyno is not getting
less accurate results, they are simply correcting to different
atmospheric conditions.  I use the old factor since it is most commonly
used for performance engines.  The luxury of claiming accuracy is for
those who can control their test conditions, not those who use the
"best" correction factor.

Paul Yaw

 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org