Subject: Rotary verses the piston aircraft engine.
From: Paul
Date: 6/24/1999, 6:45 PM
To: zz

Vance and Emily Jaqua wrote:


On Wed, 23 Jun 1999 23:52:14   Paul wrote:
I was driving home from the hangar thinking about aircraft
engines after taking two perfectly good cylinders off my
brand new O-470 so the Continental rep could check the
brand new crank for cracks tomorrow as per an AD.

It struck me that aircraft engines are so finely engineered
and developed that the least little defect or improper
assembly technique can cause them to fail. This is an
out grouth of their exceptional power to weight ratio
for such a heavy duty piston engine.

Other heavy duty engines such as found in tractor trailer
trucks are much heavier and probably more tolerant of
small manufacturing defects. These engines weigh
around 2000 pounds and put out only 250 HP or so.

This is what makes the rotary so remarkable. It is possible
to quadruple  the stock HP of a rotary by pumping it up with
a turbo charger and still not have it blow up.

You could never take a 180 HP aircraft piston engine and
pump it up to 730 HP. It would blow up long before you got
anywhere near 730 HP.

The rotary has a huge margin of reserve strength for
such a high power to weight ratio engine to begin with.

Paul Lamar



So shame on you Paul - why is there not a rotary
in your airplane? 

I would do it in an instant if the FAA would let me.
Now don't say I can unless you check with the local FSDO
and ask about all the conditions of putting your certified
airplane in the experimental category. The FAA is on to that
ploy.

You should not paint all piston
engines with the same brush as expensive replica
antiques called aircraft engines - Vance

Come on Vance you know better than that. Show me a car piston engine
that will run at 75% peak power continuously and has anywhere 
near the power to weight ratio of your run-of-the-mill air cooled
aircraft piston engine. There ain't none. This includes older German
car engines. Too heavy. The aircraft piston engine has been optimized 
for the job a long time ago. There is no piston engine technology 
out there that will make it much better than it already is. Many have
tried and many have failed. I don't want to hear about EFI/EIGN
either. Mags work without juice.

If I every get that engine back in my 182 I am going to sell it
and buy an experimental and put a rotary in it.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org