Paul Yaw wrote:
Paul wrote:
JMLBlues@aol.com wrote:
The reason "performance" engines are rated using the old correction factors
is simply that it gives a much higher figure. The old standard corrected to
60 F air temp and ZERO relative humidity. I guess if everybody uses that std,
you still have a basis for comparison. But when you take a manufacturer's
rating (corrected to 77 F and about 30% relative humidity) and then do some
magic mojo to the engine, run it for an instant on the dyno using the old
correction factors, its easy to make a claim for improved engine performance
that does not really reflect the same reality.
First, to answer Paul's question, the difference between J607, and J1985
is 4.004%.
The above scenario is not valid with any correction factor. First, the
manufacturers dyno may not give the exact numbers that yours would with
the same engine. No two brakes give the same numbers, and there are
some obvious trends to be noted among the various dyno manufacturers.
For instance, as Stuska brake will often give higher numbers than a Go
Power brake. These are realtively small differences, but 5% from one
dyno to another is not uncommon. The other thing to consider is under
what conditions did the manufacturer test the engine? Even if all the
brakes in the world gave the same numbers, and the correction factor was
accurate, you could not possibly make a valid comparison unless you knew
the original conditions for testing. You would have to know the actual
air inlet temperature, water temp, oil temp, was the engine run long
enough for the block, and manifold to heat soak etc. The only valid
comparison would be to make a pass stock, add your go fast part, and
make another pass.
It is also worth noting that the manufacturers have the luxury of
controlling their test conditions so that they do not have to apply a
correction factor.
Now, even though I am arguing with you about correction factors, I would
like to point out that I do know where you are coming from. I agree
completely that MANY horsepower quotes are BS. Especially if they
appear in a slick glossy magazine. From the tone of your first
response, I assume that you are one of the few who does not fudge your
dyno numbers, and I respect that.
As for correction factors, one inaccurate factor is not better than the
other inaccurate factor. Adding or subtracting 4% does not change the
fact that they are only a guess, and your dyno numbers, or my dyno
numbers are not directly comparable to anyone elses. As for why
performace engines normally use the old factor, why would anyone change
midstream to a different set of atmospheric conditions that does not
make their testing any more valid? If you really wanted to make a
comparison between one of my engines tested at say 90F, 20% RH, and
27.2" Hg., on a Go Power brake, and one tested at Mederer's shop at near
sea level on a Stuska brake you are kidding yourself. There are too
many variables, the biggest which is the innacuracy of the correction
itself. Now if Mederer and myself both switch to the new factor, the
percentage difference between the engines would still be the same!
While we are on the subject, I try to find a worst case scenario when
testing. Especially when the designer of the plane tells me how much
power he has to have for a successful project. The horsepower graphs
that I posted for the turbo 13B are with a muffler, no air moving past
the intercooler, and no heat shields for the manifold which is only 1"
away from the turbine. My hope is that the engine will make more power
in flight when the intercooler is being cooled effectively, and the heat
shields are installed. Because of the test conditions, I can be
confident that the horsepower will be sufficient for the application.
Your stated reason for the use of the old correction factor is your
OPINION, just as it is my OPINION that many horsepower quotes are BS.
It is a FACT that neither correction factor is more accurate than the
other as they are both an educated guess.
Paul Yaw
I think 60 degrees is good for an aircraft engine as it is cold up
there.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org