Subject: Low cost knock sensors electronics
From: Paul
Date: 7/6/1999, 10:53 PM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Paul Yaw wrote:

Paul wrote:

MAR34807@aol.com wrote:

When you "hear" the knock via earphones it is too late. The rotor seals have
been destroyed.

Paul Lamar wrote:

All of six of them?

Ceramic apex seals too?

Is there another way of detecting knock before the seals are destroyed?

Paul Lamar

Ken Powell wrote:

     Is this true for normally aspirated engines?  Is this really true for
     turbo engines?  How about some more feed back from you guys who race
     these things.  This is definitely not the case for a piston engine.
     In the 1970's the smog stuff was so bad that engines knocked often,
     usually when going up hills.  While I'm sure that the long term effect
     was bad, but this went on for years (I always backed out of the
     throttle until the 'ping' went away - note the the HP also went away).
     Yes I understand that knock will destroy any engine at max horsepower
     levels, I'm just trying to determine how vulnerable the rotary really
     is.  Maybe Paul Yaw can quantify this for us?  I'm hoping that if we
     can identify or hear incipient knock we can tune around it.

     Ken Powell


I will have to speak to Mazdatrix, Abel Ibarra and Jim Mederera
at Racing Beat about this. Don't panic :-)

Jim is running 300 HP per rotor on 100LL as we speak. He should know.

Paul Lamar

One BIG bang can destroy the seals immediately, but the engines can
survive a fair bit of minor detonation.  Mazda claims that the apex
seals jump off the housing during detonation, so I suppose that even
minor detonation will be hard on the seals, and it will definitely
destroy the engine if allowed to continue.  I have heard one of my own
engines detonate so loudly that I just about jumped out the window at 70
mph.  It survived a few of these.  I don't know how.  It sounded like
the world was coming to an end!  This was a 12A which has 3mm. seals,
and they are of course 10mm. shorter than the 13B seals.  They must
surely be stronger than the 13B 2mm. seals.  If you don't dyno the
engine (Which is absolutely crazy!) before going airborne, you should at
least find a way to run the engine at full throttle with a prop load to
tune the fuel and ignition.  If everything is right before it leaves the
ground, it will not detonate in the air unless something is very wrong.
(Like fuel starvation for instance.)

Paul Yaw

You can do it with a ground adjustable pitch  prop. 
Just set the pitch so the engine will run at 6500 RPM WOT static. 
Even if you don't intend to fly with one it is handy to have. 

All this assumes you have a PSRU. 

With a direct drive engine you will have to saw the
blades off to about 36 inches to keep the centrifugal loads down
and the tip less than supersonic or so..

Needless to say never stand or sit in the plane of the prop.

BTW if Mazda thought one detonation would destroy the engine there
would be no point in installing detonation sensors.

Again I want to emphasize the importance of an intake manifold
temperature gage on turbo or super charged engines. High intake
charge temperatures are a primary cause of detonation.
That is why the guys getting 700 HP out of a two rotor 13B are 
running ice water intercoolers and alcohol fuel. Keeps the mixture
cool. 

As I recall Tracy measures the intake manifold temperature and that
is how he sets the mixture along with manifold pressure and RPM.
He does not rely on the O2 sensor.
Perhaps we could talk Tracy into displaying this temperature number on 
the intrument panel.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org