Subject: PSRU verses direct drive small prop.
From: Paul
Date: 7/22/1999, 12:13 PM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
This is the orginal thrust data provided by Vance Jaqua
with prop efficiency added by me. Bill Freeman feels
the data for the O-235 is a little on the low side.

   LYC O 235 67X73               Wankel 37X38
speed  rpm  hp thrust eff.   rpm   hp  thrust eff. diff.
 0    2020  82    315        4890  120  299
60    2030  82    259  51%   5100  124  250   33%  -18%
100   2250  95    244  68%   5380  130  227   47%  -21%
140   2470  105   213  76%   5700  136  201   55%  -21%
180   2750  115   188  78%   6150  145  185   61%  -17%

This is a takeoff simulation for the O-235 assuming it has
a constant 82 HP  between 0 and 60 MPH and a gross weight 
of 1200 pounds with a 3 square foot equavalent flate plate area.

Sea level
 Time    MPH   Drag   Prop Eff  Thrust  Acc    Distance
  1.3    8.1    0.5      8      308    0.26      4
  1.7   10.0    0.7     10      306    0.25      7
  2.2   13.0    1.3     13      303    0.25     11
  2.8   16.0    1.9     16      300    0.25     17
  3.3   19.0    2.7     18      298    0.25     24
  3.5   20.1    3.1     19      297    0.24     27
  4.3   24.0    4.4     23      293    0.24     39
  4.5   25.1    4.8     24      292    0.24     43
  5.8   32.0    7.9     30      285    0.23     72
  6.0   33.0    8.4     31      284    0.23     76
  6.2   34.0    8.9     31      283    0.23     81
  6.4   35.0    9.4     32      283    0.23     86
  6.6   36.0   10.0     33      282    0.23     92
  7.9   42.1   13.6     38      276    0.22    127
  8.1   43.0   14.3     38      275    0.22    134
  8.7   46.1   16.4     41      272    0.21    155
  9.4   49.1   18.6     43      269    0.21    178
  9.8   51.1   20.2     44      268    0.21    194
 10.7   55.1   23.5     47      264    0.20    229
 11.2   57.0   25.2     49      262    0.20    248
 11.9   60.0   27.9     51      259    0.19    278

This is a takeoff simulation for the direct drive rotary 
assuming it has a constant 120 HP between 0 and 60 MPH 
and a gross weight of 1200 pounds with a 3 square foot 
equavalent flate plate area.

Sea level
 Time    MPH   Drag   Prop Eff  Thrust  Acc    Distance
  0.3    2.1    0.0      1      298    0.25      0
  0.8    5.0    0.2      3      295    0.25      2
  1.6    9.0    0.6      6      292    0.24      6
  1.8   10.1    0.8      7      291    0.24      7
  2.5   14.0    1.5      9      288    0.24     14
  2.7   15.1    1.7     10      287    0.24     16
  2.9   16.1    2.0     10      286    0.24     18
  6.1   32.1    7.9     19      273    0.22     75
  6.3   33.0    8.4     20      272    0.22     80
  7.2   37.1   10.6     22      269    0.22    102
  7.4   38.0   11.1     23      268    0.21    108
  7.8   40.1   12.4     24      266    0.21    120
  8.0   41.0   13.0     24      266    0.21    126
  8.5   43.1   14.3     25      264    0.21    140
  9.8   49.1   18.6     28      259    0.20    186
 10.3   51.0   20.1     29      257    0.20    203
 11.0   54.0   22.6     31      255    0.19    230
 11.2   55.1   23.5     31      254    0.19    240
 12.2   59.0   27.0     33      251    0.19    280
 12.4   60.0   27.9     33      250    0.19    290

The thrust in both cases was a linear interpolation 
between zero and 60 MPH. Time increments for
calculation purposes was .05 seconds.

I was rather surprised there was so little difference
in the takeoff performance.

The rotary probably would have about a 100 pound weight
penalty over an O-235. This fact is not included
in this simulation. This would make takeoff distances
slightly longer for the direct drive rotary.

The big hit of course will be fuel burn because
of the reduced prop eff and higher HP required.

If anybody wants these programs let me know.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org