X-Mozilla-Keys:
Tracy Crook wrote:
Sounds like I missed a lot of you guys at Oshkosh by showing up a couple of
days late. Several people wrote wondering if I had mechanical troubles due
to this and some rumors spread by a well known west coast rotary engine
builder who shall remain nameless.
I had the RV ready with the new engine, EFI controller and gear drive two
days before Oshkosh week but I was just too tired from the 110 hour work
weeks I spent getting it ready. Had to sleep for a few days. Except for
coming close to heat exhaustion during the 40 minute taxi after landing at
Osh in the 100 degree heat, the 2200 mile flight up & back was uneventful.
Total fuel burn was 86.1 gallons, total hours was 13.9 but that included
warmup & taxi time.
That is 6.2 gallons per hour in case you were wondering. Avg. HP at .5
BSFC
and six pounds of fuel per gallon was 74 HP. At .475 BSFC is was
78.2 HP. Average flying speed 166 MPH based on 13.24 flying time.
(Less the 40 minute taxi time at OSH) That is also about 27 MPG.
Not bad for 166 MPH. PL
Chris Ross is already P.O.'d at me for building a new drive so I need to
make it clear up front that I think we owe a big thanks to Ross for
pioneering in making redrives for the Mazda rotary. They were out there
actually delivering usable drives back when other companies were selling
only promises. None of the following is meant to knock the Ross company but
just a factual account of what I found after 856 hours on the drive.
As Bruce T. wrote, the first surprise found when we pulled the old (856
hour) engine was that the Ross drive had beat the input shaft spline pattern
into the end of the crankshaft. Checking the engine thrust bearing end
play, I found that it was ten times normal. It had gone from .002 to .020
inches. This convinced me that a thrust bearing for the input shaft is a
"must have" and was glad I had incorporated one in my own design. Other
than this the engine looked fine.
Rumor has it that Ross is now adding a thrust bearing to take the sun
gear
thrust loads. I think this problem with the Ross was discovered quite
some time ago on Ken Wellers Coot amphib using nitrous oxide and a six
blade
Warp Drive prop to take off. Apparently the cause was not immediately
identified as his engine went through several e-shaft thrust bearings.
Unfortunately Ken was not on the news letter or we may have heard
about it a year ago last April. PL
It was running fine when removed,
inspection of rotor housing walls through the exhaust ports looked good and
apex seals looked smooth and were all freely floating in their grooves.
Very little carbon was evident (compared to all the engines out of cars I've
inspected). Other than some increase in both the input and propeller shaft
end play, the Ross drive was working well. The Sun and planet gears as well
as the prop thrust bearing had been replaced at 650 hours. I have not had
time to do a tear down on the engine yet but I'll pass along details of what
I find when it happens.
Interested in selling that engine Tracy? I would like to see only the
thrust bearing and e-shaft fixed and put back in service to see just
how long the engine will last in aircraft service.
As a precaution, I replaced my exhaust header pipes which had turned a dark
black. I cut the old headers at the point where they ran the hottest
(outside of first 90 degree bend) and checked the wall thickness. There was
some evidence of slight scaling at this point. The .035 wall 321 stainless
tube measured .033 after 856 hours. I considered this acceptable and built
my new headers out of the same type material. After 18 hours, my shinny new
headers looked very similar to the old ones.
The new engine is basically an 89 turbo II engine with non turbo rotors to
give a compression ratio of 9.7 - 1. The engine is normally aspirated using
the latest version of my EFI controller (EC-2). This was an experiment to
see if the cleaner porting of the turbo 4 port side housings and less
restrictive exhaust port of the turbo rotor housings would equal or better
the power of the 6 port setup with its later intake port closing. The
bottom line is that it appears to make 5 - 10 more HP but since this was not
an apples to apples comparison, it's hard to make any absolute statements
about it. This engine was a full blown zero - time blueprint build (by
Bruce Turrentine) while the old engine was a minimal expense overhaul of a
junkyard engine (apex seals, oil seal o-rings & gasket kit) . I would
conclude that it really does not make a huge difference which version you
use (assumeing you do some cleanup of Mazda's horrible 6 port manifold).
I can't tell any difference in sound level while in-flight but standing
outside the plane on the ground I noticed a more aggressive "bite" to the
exhaust note. This is due to the lack of splitters in the exhaust ports of
the turbo rotor housings.
Amphib builders might like the turbo sidehousings because the more
conservative intake port timing allows the engine to idle MUCH smoother at
low rpm. I can now idle the engine down to 1000 rpm with no gear drive
chatter. 1500 was about the limit before.
I also installed the first production version of my redrive. Weight is
within 2-3 pounds of the Ross (i'll measure it more carefully later). In
order to make user inspection, maintaince & overhaul easier this drive has
two more splines in the driveline than the Ross (uses many more unmodified
Ford C6 parts than the Ross) . As a result, there is more axial play
(rotation at the prop tip) in my drive. On the other hand, virtually all
radial and end play is eliminated from the input and prop shaft due to the
use of deep groove ball bearings and pressure lubricated plain bearings
instead of needle bearings. I felt this was a better compromise for many
reasons.
How about a sketch or drawing of the guts Tracy? A photo of
the guts layed out would be nice too.
In-flight tests confirmed that elimination of radial play in the prop shaft
had eliminated the odd resonances and vibrations at various engine speeds
that I had with the Ross drive. I had speculated that these were caused by
the drive because I could see a "modulation" in sunlight reflecting off the
prop that was synchronized with the vibrations. Several builders have
described these sounds & vibrations as being like a twin engine airplane
with the engines running at slightly different speeds. This always bugged
me because it always seemed like the vibrations would be at their worst
right at the speed I wanted to run.
Fuel burn with the EC2 is a bit lower than with the earlier version. (I
tested it on the old engine so it was not due to the new engine) This is
somewhat of a mystery because there is no technical reason why this should
be. The injector pulse width control has twice the resolution on the new
version but this would not explain the change.
All in all, I'm very pleased with the new setup and I'll pass along more
findings as they come up.
Tracy Crook
rws@altavista.net
Web site: http://www.rotaryaviation.com
Thanks for the report Tracy.
BTW do you have an estimated price for the re-drive?
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org