X-Mozilla-Keys:
Bill Freeman wrote:
Jeff Spitzer wrote:
BTW Turbonetics says the ceramic ball bearing consumes
half the HP of the plain bearing version of the turbo. I am
a bit skeptical. Not counting the HP it takes to compress
and heat the air of course.
Paul Lamar
Ball bearing turbos do have considerably improved efficiency over plain
bearing ones. The difference is about 3% overall. The problem with ball
bearings is the weight of the balls spinning around so fast wears out the
outer races. Really!!! That's why ceramic balls are so important to
turbos...less ball weight and stronger to boot.
Jeff Spitzer
Do you believe the life improvements in the turbos with ceramic
ball bearings?
Paul Lamar
jelkil@interaccess.com wrote:
kevin wyum on the rx-7 list has twin ceramic turbos on his car. I think he
overspeeded them to destruction due to wastegate failure, but should be
running again already.
Tom
Apples and Oranges Tom. Ceramic ball bearings are different than
ceramic turbines. Ceramic turbines are notoriously fragile.
On the other hand ceramic ball bearings are widely used in high
speed NC milling machines.
Since the density of the ceramic balls is only half of that of steel
balls I would be skeptical about using them in a turbo designed to
run at high speed all the time such as would be used in an aircraft
engine.
Paul Lamar
Did I miss something? The lighter ceramic balls are *good* because
they are lower density and therefore their own mass * omega squared
is a lot lower, meaning the load up the outer race due to their own
weight a lot less. This should mean longer life, and moreso at higher
RPMs. Most ceramics are very good at high temp, too -- another
possible plus. How is the fatigue life fo the ceramics, as this is how
balls fail in ball bearings (Hertzian contact stresses eventually cause
subsurface cracks and chunks spall off).
Bill
Just delete that sentence guys. Sorry I was so un-clear.
Regular ball bearings don't work. Ceramic BB's are twice as
good as regular BB's. Two times zero is zero.
Plain oil pressure fed bearings are the way to go.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org