X-Mozilla-Keys:
Russell Kent wrote:
It seems to me that since both alternators are turning all the time
[causing wear] and exposed to the same environmental factors which might
cause failure, that the presence of two alternators just gives you double
the chance of an alternator failure.
Has anyone ever looked close enough at an air conditioning compressor?
Can the clutch system be connected to and be used by the alternator? If
so, it can be engaged with a switch.
This idea is used by Mercedes Benz on their A.I.R. (smog) pumps. They
are used on their V-8s of the 1980s. This could be adapted by modifying
either the alternator shaft or the A.I.R. pump clutch receiving hole.
Charlie Kuss
And the supercharges in the Kompressor models.
Paul Lamar
This discussion about using clutches on alternators is all well and good, but I'd like
to interject a little speculative engineering in here.
1. I'm under the impression that both superchargers and auto air conditioner
compressors use gobs of HP. Consequently their clutch mechanisms may be overkill
for a standby alternator.
2. The clutch mechanism for every auto air conditioner compressor I've ever seen was
an electrically-actuated, normally-disengaged device. I assume supercharger
clutches are the same. Don't forget to add the current draw from the clutch to
your amperage requirements.
3. The electric clutch is yet another failure possibility. Anybody have a handle on
their failure rate?
4. The electric clutch adds weight.
Finally, perhaps we should investigate the root causes of alternator failure before
engineering a clutch for it. I've only had one alternator fail, and that was a 1965
Ford Mustang model (probably not original equipment either). IIRC, it failed due to
diode failure / open circuit. I cannot imagine that failure mode had the slightest
thing to do with whether the alternator was turning. Pure speculation here, but I bet
most alternator failures are unrelated to whether the alternator was turning, but
rather due to electrical failure of some sub-component, and that sub-component's
failure was due to common semiconductor failure modes: vibration-induced
breakage/delamination, ion contaminate migration (commonly chlorine or oxygen),
thermal-cycle induced failures, and over-voltage, over-current, or reverse-bias
failures. The things that I would expect to see fail if "turning" was a factor in
failure would be: bearing failure, and electrical brush failure.
All you professional mechanics out there: what's your experience with failed
alternators? When they fail, do you know why?
Russell Kent
One thing on the HP issue a 70 amp alternator 14 volts is providing
980 watts. At 80% efficiency that is really about 1180 watts.
Converted to HP that is about 1.6. No small amount.
Course the standby could be half that.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org