X-Mozilla-Keys:
Mike Wills wrote:
At 04:37 PM 9/2/1999 -0700, you wrote:
Russell Kent wrote:
This discussion about using clutches on alternators is all well and
good, but I'd like
to interject a little speculative engineering in here.
Russell,
I'm with you. The original goal in this thread was to add some redundancy
to the electrical system. Some say that the battery and alternator already
provide redundancy but as was pointed out by Ed A., a failed battery can
lead to alternator over-voltage. Not good enough for my airplane.
So we are left with either a back-up battery or a back-up alternator.
Either approach is viable and both have positives and negatives. The
argument against the back-up alternator that was mentioned here earlier
(less reliability because there are now twice as many things to break) just
doesnt add up for me. The real concern is if they both break at the same
time. What are the odds on that? Using the twice as many things to break
argument could be justification for having a single electric fuel pump,
single ignition, or for that matter a single battery. IMHO a backup battery
is more likely to be dead from disuse when you really need it, than
suffering a dual alternator failure.
Then we went into clutches to put the alt in standby. Unnecessary
engineering, weight, and complexity in my book. Disable the internal
regulator in the alternator, use an external regulator (there are good
arguments for doing this; read Bob Nuckolls' book), and break the field
winding with a switch to disable the standby alternator when necessary.
The paragraph from Bob Nuckolls that I posted here yesterday is very
intrigueing to me. Dual alternators and dual batteries (for starting) with
less weight than the typical electrical system. But I'm still on the fence
because I think I might actually need the battery weight in the baggage
compartment for cg reasons. That will probably determine what I decide to do.
And Tracy, I'd still be interested in hearing what your typical current
draw is in normal day VFR flight, transponder on, radio on, etc...
Mike Wills
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org