Subject: Batteries and standby alternator.
From: Paul
Date: 9/2/1999, 10:04 PM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Charles P. Kuss wrote:

  1. I'm under the impression that both superchargers and auto air conditioner
     compressors use gobs of HP.  Consequently their clutch mechanisms may be overkill
     for a standby alternator.
  2. The clutch mechanism for every auto air conditioner compressor I've ever seen was
     an electrically-actuated, normally-disengaged device.  I assume supercharger
     clutches are the same.  Don't forget to add the current draw from the clutch to
     your amperage requirements.
  3. The electric clutch is yet another failure possibility.  Anybody have a handle on
     their failure rate?
  4. The electric clutch adds weight.

All you professional mechanics out there: what's your experience with failed
alternators?  When they fail, do you know why?

Russell Kent

Russell,
 You have made several valid points. The reason I suggested using the
Mercedes A.I.R. pump clutch is because these units do not require as
hefty a clutch unit as an A/C compressor does. There may well be other
more approriate units available, I simply am unaware of them.

 I often (but not always) know what destroys an alternator. (Yeah, I'm a
professional wrench spinner). Allowing the backup alternator to free
wheel at the pulley will insure that it is not destroyed, providing that
it is also electrically isolated from the system when unused.

 Consider the following scenerio. Joe pilot comes out to fly his plane
only to find the battery dead. He jumps the battery to start the plane
and taxies out. This causes the alternator to provide maximum output
(even over max rated output) This sort of abuse is very hard on the
rectifier diodes.

 A battery with an internal cell problem does not always make itself
known right away. Often a cronic low battery charge will cause the
premature demise of an alternator. The cause is a mini version of the
scenario above, repeated over and over till failure. A poor ground or
output (Bat +) terminal connection will cause this as well over time.

 The backup alternator will be unaffected by these IF it has it's own
dedicated wiring harness. The backup alternator clutch will not be
engaged during normal operation, so there will be no extra load on the
system except during it's use in an emergency.

 It's basic purpose is to get you safely on the ground when the primary
unit dies in IFR conditions. Mike Will's suggestion of electrically
isolating the backup alternator's field circuit and allowing the unit
to spin has merit.

 This however does not relieve the stress on the rectifier diodes, as
the they are still resisting the reversal of the current in the output
(Bat +) circuit. There would still be a slim chance of both rectifiers
failing simultaneously due to the scenarios presented above OR a
sudden massive short. Isolating the output circuit as well as the field
circuit and allowing the backup unit to spin would be another option.
It's your plane, you make the call.
Charlie Kuss

 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org