Subject: Tracy's 856 hour Engine teardown, kisbuilders@angus.mystery.com
From: Paul
Date: 9/30/1999, 12:06 PM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Tracy Crook wrote:

Finally got around to doing the teardown of the old engine (856 hours flight
time).  The results were better than I had hoped for.  It should be
remembered that this was a used 1986 13B engine with between 50 - 70
thousand miles on it when I gave it a minimal overhaul. It ran well but had
been overheated bad enough to ruin the oil seal o-rings and smoked badly.
The only parts replaced were the apex seals, oil seal O-rings and some side
seal springs.

This was the first rotary I had ever seen but now after tearing down about a
dozen 13Bs with various milage, I know it was not in particularly good
shape.  I have seen 130,000 mile engines in better condition.  I say this
because it is difficult to characterize the condition of some parts
(especially rotor housings) in hard numbers.

The first thing I noticed was how little carbon there was in the seal
grooves.  Until you have torn down a typical 13B from a car you can't
appreciate this but almost all the rotor seals fell out with nothing more
than gravity to help.  Even the side seal springs came out with just a
gentle tug.  I had to dig the originals out with the help of an X-acto knife
and most of them broke.    There was a moderate amount of carbon on the
faces of the rotors but it was the soft, easily removed variety which  took
only a few minutes with a single edge razor blade and a brass wire brush to
remove.  I estimate that total cleaning time to prepare this engine for
overhaul would be about an hour.  I spent two full  DAYS cleaning it the
first time.  I attribute the lack of carbon in the grooves to the use of two
stroke oil in the fuel instead of using  the factory oil injection.
(instead of straight Marvel Mystery Oil , I now mix two stroke oil half &
half with MMO and use one ounce of this mixture per gallon of fuel)

The water jacket O-rings looked good and I was able to pull them out in one
piece. (which is unusual).  The oil would not explain why these grooves were
so clean.  Maybe it was the Hylomar?  Or perhaps it was the relatively few t
hermal cycles the engine gets compared to a car.

The wear on the apex seals was the smallest I have seen on any engine.  Only
did a quick measurement on one of them so far but they all look the same.
Looks like about .017" off the height of the seal. The face of the seal was
perfectly smooth and rounded with no chamfering.

 Wear on main & rotor bearings was not measurable.  These things almost
never seem to be worn.  Same story on the E shaft bearing surfaces.  Side
seal wear while in the plane was only  .00025 - .0005" (they had .002" wear
from their previous life in a car).
The oil pump drive chain had over 5/8 inch "flop" in it which was a little
more than it had originally.  It probably should have been changed.

I already reported on the thrust bearing wear due to thrust transfered from
the Ross drive.  It was very worn (about .020") but oddly, there was no
fretting or galling of the needles or races.  They were smoothly worn.  The
needles were worn to a tapered shape and the diameter was reduced enough
that many of them fell out of the cage when it was removed.  The thrust
bearing on the other side of the thrust plate (virtually unloaded) was like
new.

When I assembled the engine, the rotor housings were not in very good
condition compared with what I would now consider to be "good".  They fit
the description of what I now call "usable".  The total rotor housing wear
was not directly measurable with the tools that I have.  After looking at
enough of these things you can usually judge them by eye.
In spite of their so-so condition when put back in service, they held up
remarkably well.  The groove worn by the apex seal corner piece had not
increased in depth and there was no further "chiping " of the chrome between
the groove and edge. (we are talking about very tiny chips here)  There were
no scratches and no noticible wearing of the chrome surface in spite of the
fact that I never ran an aircleaner.  The best idea I can give you is to say
that they looked exactly the way they looked when I put the engine back
together 5 1/2 years ago.  If I were putting together an engine for my
airplane today I'd probably replace them, but on the other hand,  I'd fly
them again if I didn't have the money.

Everett Hatch expressed a lot of concern for what he called "coking" on the
inside of the rotor housing.  This shows up as carbonized oil in the area
just after the minor axis on the spark plug side which will be about the
hottest area on the housing.  He went to great lengths to improve cooling
here in an effort to eliminate this coking and cracking around the sparkplug
holes.  There was some sign of coking on both of the rotor housings but it
was very minor and could be easily removed just by spraying on some solvent
(I had PB Blaster laying around) and rubbing it with a fingertip.  I don't
think it is anything to get concerned about and I think the cause may be due
to the apex seal skipping over this area after going over the "ski jump" at
the minor axis.  There is very little pressure in the chamber when the apex
seal arrives at this point because the exhaust port has just opened, in one
case, or entering the compression cycle in the other.   There was no sign of
any cracks around the spark plug holes.

Along with the apex seals, I was most interested in how the sidehousings
held up.  The point of maximun wear is a step near the minor axis on the
sparkplug side where the side and corner seals exert maximum pressure.  The
step measured about .002" when overhauled.  The step had increased to
.00225 - .0025", still less than the factory limit of .0039".   One
interesting point was that the step is usually about 1.5" wide in car
engines (even when the depth is as much as .005) but mine were now almost
double that.  There is no factory spec on how wide it can be.  I think the
width of the step may be a function of average power the engine is run at.
I'll post more details on the website in a few weeks.

Sorry, the engine is not for sale.  It's sentimental value alone prevents me
from parting with it.

My overall conclusion is that the engine is easily capable of 2000 hour TBO
in aircraft service (assuming you ditch the oil injection and eliminate the
thrust from the re-drive).  Check back with me in about 5 years and I'll
know for sure  :-)

Tracy Crook
rws@altavista.net
http://www.rotaryaviation.com

What! No burn't exhaust valves? You've got to be kidding.:-)

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org